I'm re-reading The Hobbit at the moment. Gandalf might not be a conjurer of cheap tricks, because he's only packing the expensive, high-caliber stuff.
#tolkien #meme #hobbit #gandalf #wizard #fantasy #badlydrawn #dnd
I'm re-reading The Hobbit at the moment. Gandalf might not be a conjurer of cheap tricks, because he's only packing the expensive, high-caliber stuff.
3 years ago by Imperor 🎲🎮 to c/rpgmemes
load all comments
Imperor 39 points 3 years ago
path: 0 6095418 6095611, hotness: undefined, score: 39, children: 4
The Hobbit has a narrator, who speaks from a "modern" perspective. It describes in the beginning how Hobbits are few now and avoid the tall folk, all that. So I'm fairly sure this is the narrator giving a frame of reference, rather than Bilbo knowing the smell.
Later it is also said that Orcs are cunning inventors of things that kill, including things that kill a lot of people at once.
Not only that, but in LoTR Helms Deeps outer wall is blown up with gun powder or similar.
usualsuspect191 16 points 3 years ago
I thought the Hobbit was meant to be written by Bilbo so a modern narrator explains it.
I knew there were things like explosives and fireworks, but unless guns are a common use, calling black powder "gunpowder" is weird so I wouldn't expect middle earth to have that word.
yeather 12 points 3 years ago
I thought the Hobbit was written by Bilbo as an account of his tales only to be translated at a later date by the narrator. Which explains why place names are in the original language but the rest of the book is in english.
CeruleanRuin 1 point 3 years ago
There are also things like cuckoo clocks and a reference to a train.
go to feed...
go to feed...
Are there guns in LOTR? How would Bilbo know the smell of gunpowder or call it as such?
save