This suggestion is to add 16 new blocks which are opaque to the light engine but rendered transparently.
There would be two crafting recipes for each Tinted Stained Glass:
One Dye plus eight Tinted Glass produces eight Tinted Stained Glass.
One Stained Glass plus four Amethyst Shards produces one Tinted Stained Glass.
Both recipes use the same amount of Amethyst Shards and the same amount Glass.
The recipe using Amethyst and Stained Glass uses half as much dye as the other.
The recipe using Tinted Glass and Dye would be present for players who upgrade their world and had previously crafted lots of Tinted Glass.
Tinted glass recipe — 8 tinted glass = 4 glass + 16 amethyst
First suggested recipe — 8 tinted stained glass = 4 glass + 16 amethyst + 1 dye
Second suggested recipe: — 8 tinted stained glass = 8 glass + 32 amethyst + 1 dye
Maybe I'm doing my math wrong, but the second suggested recipe seems way more expensive.
Either way, I'm just unnecessarily nitpicking recipe numbers. The actual idea itself is cool.
@kbin.social
The official unofficial magazine for discussing Minecraft ideas! Counterpart of /r/minecraftsuggestions on Reddit. ### Important Links _**Expanded Rules**_ _**Frequently Posted Suggestions (FPS)**_ _**MCS Discord Server**_ ### Rules 1 | Be nice and constructive. 2 | Speak English. 3 | Only post ideas for Minecraft. 4 | Be original and consult the FPS list. 5 | Don't include multiple independent ideas in one post. 6 | Be concise but specific. 7 | Don't suggest planned or existing features (including parity). 8 | Don't suggest scrapped or unused features without significant reworks. 9 | Don't suggest jokes, easter eggs, or overly unrealistic ideas.
go to feed...
@kbin.social
The official unofficial magazine for discussing Minecraft ideas! Counterpart of /r/minecraftsuggestions on Reddit. ### Important Links _**Expanded Rules**_ _**Frequently Posted Suggestions (FPS)**_ _**MCS Discord Server**_ ### Rules 1 | Be nice and constructive. 2 | Speak English. 3 | Only post ideas for Minecraft. 4 | Be original and consult the FPS list. 5 | Don't include multiple independent ideas in one post. 6 | Be concise but specific. 7 | Don't suggest planned or existing features (including parity). 8 | Don't suggest scrapped or unused features without significant reworks. 9 | Don't suggest jokes, easter eggs, or overly unrealistic ideas.
go to feed...
This could be nice for decor. The main issue I see is that tinted glass is already quite black, so I'm not sure if it would make sense for dye to add much color to it.
The first recipe is fine, but the second one is really bad. It's worse than both the first recipe and the normal tinted glass recipe (1 glass + 4 amethyst → 2 tinted glass). I think it'd be best to just have the first one — because of how different stained & tinted stained glass would probably look, I doubt people would be converting from one to the other.
save