2 Questions about Lemmy Accounts
3 years ago by withloveandloathing to c/lemmyworld
If an account is created on any specific server, like !Lemmy.world does that mean if the server does shut down, the account data is lost?
Also for username availability, could we create an account in a different server where the name is not used yet?
Agreed. Lemmy needs “multireddits.” Currently it’s design is both a blessing and a curse - if one community goes toxic, it’s easy to find and join a rival community in another instance - that’s the blessing. But the segregation between similar communities is also the curse that you’ve described. Plus, if a popular instance goes dark, there goes that community. Multis would help alleviate both issues.
My understanding on this is yes there will be multiples in some cases. But you could subscribe to all of them. (I personally don't think there will ever be a million funny's as it a pretty broad title.) If you want this community you should make it! I'll join!
One case I see this being a good thing could be regional stuff. Like say a community based on a local eSports league, you wouldn't have to worry about all the other leagues taking the good names. You just name it eSports and people from your city join your eSports community if they wish.
It really is small(ish) community focused, instead of Reddit's massive communities.
I understand that those may be beneficial, but I struggle to see any “aggregation” happening when every server can have every duplicate of every community. Think of how much disinformation will exist from bots creating duplicate communities from large lemmy servers on small lemmy servers then posting what’s NOT the community creators desired content. It’s difficult enough to moderate a community without having to explain that lemmy.world’s “funny” community is different and doesn’t contain the same content as “funny” on a different server. This is not aggregation.
Does seem easy to add tho right? A setting that says, any community with the same name get added together, kind of like multi-reddits. Instead of multi-reddit (science+art) It could be (Funny+Epicfunny+....)
Also going back to regional stuff, users could have language or regional specifics:
Funny+EpicFunny+GermanFunny Funny+EpicFunny+CanadianFunny Maybe us Canadians have different humor that doesn't translate. Lemmy can be more focused.
Good point about abuse from bots, but that's where running your own community comes in
Again though, you’re leaving the aggregation up to the user. They would have to know of the existence of those other communities to even add them via multi style. To my knowledge we weren’t looking for more focused, we were looking for an aggregation platform like Reddit without the monetization of our content and moderation efforts.
Yes and yes.
Your user "exists" on the instance you registered on. Think of it as creating a user on gmail, and a user on yahoo mail. Two separate users tied to each mail service. If yahoo mail were to shut down, all your messages in yahoo mail would be gone. Any messages you sent to gmail would still exist in gmail though. So, any posts or comments you had made outside your instance (on other instances) would still exist. You just wouldn't be able to log in as that user anymore.
If the account user name you want is taken on lemmy.ml, you can sign up on lemmy.world or beehaw.org or some other instance, then browse from there. Keep in mind, that even if your "account profile" name is taken, you can still set your display name in settings to what you wanted.
I feel like it makes it easier for someone to mimic/impersonate another user. How do you know if that user is the actual user? I know you can open their profile but it'd be inconvenient especially in an active conversation.
This could lead to misunderstanding and even security risks.
Thank you for a great response. +1 Lemmeducation
Hey @ruud@lemmy.world, do you have any input on this? (Thank you for lemmy.world btw 🙃)
Hi! If a server shuts down, all accounts are gone. Same as with any Fediverse server.
For lemmy.world (as for mastodon.world) I make sure I have
@lemmy.world
This Community is intended for posts about the Lemmy.world server by the admins.
For support with issues at Lemmy.world, go to the Lemmy.world Support community.
Any support requests are best sent to info@lemmy.world e-mail.
If you would like to make a donation to support the cost of running this platform, please do so at the following donation URLs.
If you can, please use / switch to Ko-Fi, it has the lowest fees for us
go to feed...
@lemmy.world
This Community is intended for posts about the Lemmy.world server by the admins.
For support with issues at Lemmy.world, go to the Lemmy.world Support community.
Any support requests are best sent to info@lemmy.world e-mail.
If you would like to make a donation to support the cost of running this platform, please do so at the following donation URLs.
If you can, please use / switch to Ko-Fi, it has the lowest fees for us
go to feed...
These are great questions. I have the same about communities: if I create “Funny” on this Lemmy.world, does that prevent someone from creating a “Funny” community on another Lemmy server? If it does not, will there be millions of “Funny” communities?
save