I personally like NLT Media's offerings. I'm currently playing through the Genesis Order and recently finished Treasure of Nadia and enjoyed the stories for the series.

Other winners for me include A House in the Rift, What a Legend, and Mythic Manor as a somewhat distant third. There are plenty of games with engaging stories but I'm drawing a blank atm.

I've been really impressed by eternum, but I also really like becoming a dik because the gameplay is actually important and a lot of fun.

Harem Hotel, and Once Upon a Lifetime (Eternum Author's first game) for story.

Mythic Manor is also some decent humor and cute stories.

Good girl gone bad Our red string From Eva Kiss

Love of Magic has a good story, and it's nearing completion so now is a pretty good moment to pick it up. It also holds up well to multiple playthroughs, there are things that characters say early on that take on a while different meaning once you understand more about the world and its history.

Succumate, Summer Memories and Meltys Quest for me.

Shower with your dad simulator