China isn’t imperialist – here’s the proof

6 days ago by ☆ Yσɠƚԋσʂ ☆ to c/socialism

YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.
load all comments
Mandarbmax -5 points 6 days ago

The definition of imperialism used in this video is doubly flawed. First it requires that the nation be capitalist (which just leads into useless arguments about what China's economic system is and into arguments about imperialism vs sparkling exploitation) and it also requires that the exploitation happen outside the borders of the country being examined for imperialism (which is such a bad framework that it might imply that Israel isn't imperialist because they claim Palestinian territory). They could have ended the video with just that definition and then said that no matter what China does it is ontologically and definitionally incapable of imperialism, at worst all it can do is sparkling oppression. The video does go on to talk about how China is a lot better to foreign countries than the west is but oddly omits any mention of tibet or territory disputes around the South China sea, or what China clearly wishes to do with taiwan. The video is absolutely white washing china and making it seem like an uwu small bean who would never hurt anyone.

In not acknowledging the negative side of China it also gets in the way of a frank and earnest comparison with western imperialism and how China still is better (not blackbagging foreign heads of state for cheap oil for example). This makes China look bad, as if the truth of the situation needs to be covered up, and by comparison that the west is less bad.

This is a bad video.

path: 0 26199822, hotness: undefined, score: -5, children: 6
elixir_fan 1 point 6 days ago

You seem to be very misinformed about China, if you don't know what Tibet was like before (it was comparable to chattel slavery), or how you seem to believe China just wants to annihilate Taiwan, as if they couldn't just wait for them to agree to a peaceful reunification. Ironically China did do bad things in the past, such as siding with the Pol Pot when they had a falling out with the USSR, but you'd rather repeat propaganda.

path: 0 26199822 26202405, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 2
psycholocomotor 1 point 2 days ago

Your comment history passes the vibe test.

path: 0 26199822 26202405 26271526, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
Mandarbmax -1 points 5 days ago

So, regarding Pol Pot, you agree with my assessment that this video white washes china even though they are still less bad than the west/united states?

path: 0 26199822 26202405 26203742, hotness: undefined, score: -1, children: 0
socialism
socialism

@lemmy.ml

login for more options
7044
750
1097

Rules TBD.

go to feed...