Retrospective Discussion | Doctor Who (2005) | 3x01 "Smith and Jones"

3 days ago by ValueSubtracted to c/doctorwho

Written by: Russell T Davies

Directed by: Charles Palmer

SpaceScotsman 2 points 3 days ago

I really enjoy this opener. Martha's introduction feels a lot more fleshed out than Rose's. We know more about the Doctor, so its a bit easier as we're only introducing one new character. I like that Martha feels a bit more clued in than Rose/Donna from the get go. It fits with what 10 seems to be doing, which is somewhere between an interview for a companion and being in denial about needing company. Martha's justification for wanting to leave, having a lot of domestic trouble, is a lot more compelling than Rose's who seemed just a bit bored with life. One thing that did bug me was the Doctor-Martha kiss, while I understand the logic of 10's plan there were obviously better ways of transferring DNA which would be less invasive, and in a modern context this didn't age well.

Throughout this there's quite a high energy, mostly quick movement from scene to scene, and the threats feel genuine. The straw bit is a funny joke, and is probably peak dark humour in this episode. There's also comedy in the curmudgeony old timer handing out the old "I'm just about to retire and relax with my grandkids", shortly before he gets offed. Time lords needing 2-heart CPR is a fun idea as long as you don't think too hard about it. There's plenty of references as well. Mr Saxon. Ronald Biggs, a fugitive of the great train robbery is mentioned. Continuity around Martha's cousin as gets thrown in.

On the sci-fi side, I enjoyed the idea of a vampire that uses shapeshifting to hide their insides rather than their outsides. Overriding an MRI scanner to output 50 KiloTeslas is a bit of a reach, considering the hospital is probably running off of emergency generators. Wikipedia tells me that's somewhere around the equivalent of a neutron star. ACAB applies to the space police as well, I guess, though it's a bit unclear exactly what their status as mercenaries is. I enjoyed the mask design of the judoon - space rhinos is a monster design I've never seen anywhere else. The whole Judoon "we're going to do whatever we want" and the ship designs feels reminiscent of the Vogons from Hitchiker's.

There's a lot going on in this one and I enjoyed it.

Observation: Another hospital series opener. Rose's second series, Martha's, Donna's is medical-adjacent, Amy's climaxes in a village hospital, and Clara's in the Dalek Asylum. Hospitals make for an interesting setting because there's lots that can go wrong, and they can feel like very liminal spaces with all the closeness to death and white antiseptic spaces.

path: 0 26284522, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 2
ValueSubtracted 2 points 2 days ago

I like that Martha feels a bit more clued in than Rose/Donna from the get go.

RTD really did the Earthbound continuity better than anyone (really, I don't think anyone else even tried). One oddity in this episode is Martha commenting on the alien incursions of the past couple of years, and yet Morgenstern later spouts off that Mr. Saxon was right in his belief in extraterrestrials.

The straw bit is a funny joke, and is probably peak dark humour in this episode.

I like that stupid straw a lot - the episode strikes a pretty good balance of madcap insanity. Anne Reid plays the plasmavore with a good energy, as well.

Martha's an enjoyable character, but it's a real shame she gets bogged down by the unrequited love arc. It works well enough in this episode - the Doctor's behaviour throughout the adventure could easily be mistaken for flirting, and how can you not fall in love with David Tennant just a little bit? But it's a shame it didn't end here.

Stray thought: small universe syndrome aside, I sort of wish Clive's girlfriend Annalise had been Nerys instead.

I think it's pretty common knowledge, but "Judoon platoon upon the moon" was written into the script specifically because it would be hard for David Tennant to say with an English accent.

path: 0 26284522 26297038, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 1
SpaceScotsman 2 points a day ago

Totally agreed on the unnecessary Martha love arc.

Nerys making a surprise appearance would have been amazing.

path: 0 26284522 26297038 26315061, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
ValueSubtracted 1 point 3 days ago

I won't be able to sit and watch this one until tomorrow, but I'm looking forward to it. It's been a while.

path: 0 26280614, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
doctorwho
doctorwho

@startrek.website

login for more options
432
410
166

A community for discussing all things Doctor Who.


Rules

1 Be constructive

All posts/comments must be thoughtful and balanced.


2 Be welcoming

It is important that everyone from newbies to longtime fans feel welcome, no matter their gender, sexual orientation, religion or race.


3 Be truthful

All posts/comments must be factually accurate and verifiable. We are not a place for gossip, rumors, or manipulative or misleading content.


4 Be nice

If a polite way cannot be found to phrase what it is you want to say, don't say anything at all. Insulting or disparaging remarks about any human being are expressly not allowed.


5 Spoilers

Utilize the spoiler system for any and all spoilers relating to the most recently-aired episode. Spoiler protection will not be granted to information that is out in the mainstream media.


6 Keep on-topic

All submissions must be directly about the DW franchise (the shows, movies, books, etc.). Off-topic discussions are welcome at c/Quarks.


7 Meta

Questions and concerns about moderator actions should be brought forward via DM.


Upcoming Episodes

Date Episode Title
12-07 TWB 1x01 "Homo Aqua"
12-07 TWB 1x02 "Plastic Apocalypse"
12-14 TWB 1x03 "The Deep"
12-14 TWB 1x04 "The Witch of the Waterfall"
12-21 TWB 1x05 "The End of the War"

Doctor Who Wiki


go to feed...