What are your experiences with polyamory, first or second hand?

3 years ago by LegionEris [she/her] to c/asklemmy

I personally am in a phenomenally stable polyamorous relationship. I've been married to my wife for 12 years, and she has had the same boyfriend for about half of that time. It's a really fulfilling arrangement for all of us in various ways. We're all genuinely happy and satisfied. I'm kind of casually looking for a boyfriend of my own.

But I feel like I only hear negative stories about other poly experiences. It's always unstable people and situations. It's always two out of three people happy at most. Surely there are other success stories out there, and I just hear the disasters because they're more memorable and fun to tell. Does anyone else have or know a polyamory success story?

EDIT: This blew up a little while I was asleep. I promise I'm at least reading every comment.

EDIT 2.0: ngl I did not expect the trope of polyamory to fix a struggling relationship would be so real. We did just the opposite and are both baffled. Don't use volitility to fight the volitility.

load all comments

LadyLikesSpiders 35 points 3 years ago

I'm monogamous myself, but personally know two different polyamorous relationships. 1 is pretty damn good, and the other is rife with drama. Besides that, I tangentially know of others, and all of those are rough, though since I'm hearing of these from mutual friends and acquaintances, I could just be getting the juicy drama and none of the good parts. Could very well be that my info on those are bad

It does seem to mirror the general expectation, though, that most are unstable, and I wouldn't call it surprising. Relationships are complicated, and anything that has more moving parts is going to be more complicated. I'm not trying to suggest here that monogamy is the way to go by any means--different people have different wants and needs, and some people are just good for polyamory. I just think that a working arrangement like this is tough to pull off

Besides, this gets asked a lot about polyamorous relationships, but there are so many fucked heteronormative relationships, and you never see the argument that monogamy is wrong, so yeah. Just whatever makes you happy

save

path: 0 5228705, hotness: undefined, score: 35, children: 6

TheDoozer 7 points 3 years ago

Most of the heteronormative relationships I've known of or experienced were rife with drama and problems, so I would assume poly relationships would be, too. Even if the rate is the same, you'll be at least twice as likely to end up with a shitty relationship in a poly relationship (with at least one partner), right?

Doesn't mean there's anything wrong with poly relationships, only that there's plenty wrong with people.

save

path: 0 5228705 5230234, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 1

perviouslyiner 0 points 3 years ago

save

path: 0 5228705 5230234 5231043, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 0

captainlezbian 5 points 3 years ago

Yeah you can hold a bad traditional relationship together with duct tape and societal expectations indefinitely. You shouldn’t but there’s no kaboom or juicy details. Polyamory has more room for the failure to be catastrophic instead of a slow long decay to a couple snidely commenting on each other in a retirement home.

save

path: 0 5228705 5233512, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 0

BananaTrifleViolin 2 points 3 years ago

True although I think most relationships are unstable and have drama particularly when young, which is why people can move through so many. Most people have multiple relationships in their lives until they find someone that works (or keep going). That's seen as normal.

I think there is a bias when people look at poly relationships as they seem novel and if they fail it's easy to say it was because it was poly. But if a 2 partner relationship fails it's "normal" and we accept all the reasons like "I didntnlove them anymore" or "we grew apart" etc.

save

path: 0 5228705 5232035, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 2

captainlezbian 2 points 3 years ago

There’s also the fact that in polyamory ending is not necessarily a failure for a relationship. Monogamy has an expectation of forever or certain circumstances. But in polyamory it’s sometimes acknowledged that a casual relationship can end in everyone having gotten everything they wanted out of it and deciding to move on.

save

path: 0 5228705 5232035 5233545, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0

LadyLikesSpiders 1 point 3 years ago

Yeah, I just think the poly relationship has more places where things can go wrong. In a monogamous one, you need to two people who like each other and are compatible. In a poly, even with only 3 people, you need A and B to be compatible, A and C, and C and B. Adding one extra person into the mix complicates the relationship 3-fold depending on the nature of those relationships. They don't all have to be in a relationship with one another, but you're still adding more avenues for drama and collapse in one relationship, not to mention how one relationship could impact the other. If A is having drama with C, the frustration of that failing connection could also impact their relationship with B. I think it's easier to fail not by any sort of moral failing of polyamorous people, only that the nature of those relationships is inherently less stable through its myriad of moving parts

But there is for sure an element of bias, where heteronormativity gets a pass for being the standard

save

path: 0 5228705 5232035 5244580, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0

A Fediverse community for open-ended, thought provoking questions

Rules: (interactive)

Partnered Communities:

A Fediverse community for open-ended, thought provoking questions

Rules: (interactive)

Partnered Communities: