After reading the communityâs pinned âRules Breakdownâ post, I can easily see how Your post violated their rules. đ¤ˇââď¸ And as another poster in this thread points out, it appears Youâre just on a time-out, not a perma-ban.
Also, I will capitalize âyouâ for You as an act of politeness, but I very strongly disagree with characterizing this as âmisgenderingâ, even after reading Your âIntroduction to capitalised pronounsâ post. Yes, grammar is socially defined and arbitrary. For example, the only reason African-American Vernacular English is labelled âimproperâ is because so many (white) people with power say so â thereâs nothing inherently worse or better about it. However, itâs still necessary to reach consensus on the meaning of words, else no one could be understood.
Capitalization of Your pronoun is clearly very important to You, and it would be thus be unkind of me to refuse to accommodate You when itâs pointed out, but English is not a language where every pronoun is gendered. The capitalized version is an honorific form of the same pronoun, not a different pronoun altogether. And generally speaking, the use of honorifics (âsirâ and âmaâamâ being the most common ones) is becoming far less common these days. Perhaps itâs because honorifics are most frequently used to establish dominance and subservience roles, whether that be in customer service roles (âyes, sirâ) or governing roles (âyes, Your Honourâ or âyes, Your Majestyâ). To borrow Your own example, even many Christians now refer to their god as âheâ rather than âHeâ in written language. And of course, those of us who totally reject the notion of gods certainly donât. Your insistence on capitalization as respect for Your divinity makes me genuinely uncomfortable as someone who doesnât believe in divinity at all and certainly shouldnât feel subservient to You.