It's quite impressive how much the Immich folks have achieved in a relatively short period of time! I'm glad you found something that works for you :)

I'd say Immich has quite a few more features, with the primary focus of backing up your media from your mobile devices with a more "managed" approach (it takes care of storing and organizing the files).

Photofield is more minimalistic (both in terms of user interface and as an application) and more useful if you have an existing directory structure that you want to view as a gallery. It also pulls a few neat tricks to make it work smoothly with up to ~600k files.

See also the linked comparison for more details. It's mostly accurate, though video is a bit better with this release.

Sorry if these are stupid questions.

Not at all! Thanks for taking an interest.

Does this only show these foss_photo_libraries and your local photos?

I'm not sure what you mean. foss_photo_libraries is a comparison table of different apps someone else maintains, but I thought it was a useful resource. The photos in the demo are a subset of the open images dataset and a couple of other samples that I picked for demo purposes.

If you install it locally you can point it to a folder and it should use each subfolder as an album, or you can configure custom albums.

Does it support jpegXL?

Yes actually, but I don't have many files to test it, so I'm not sure how well it works. If you do I'd be interested to hear how it works for you. It uses FFmpeg to on-the-fly convert anything it can't read natively.

I’d love a seamless zoom feature for images in the browser. I use imagus but I’d love if the popup window could zoom to be bigger than the browser window.

You can zoom by using the mouse wheel or by pinching to zoom if that's what you mean? You should be able to zoom pretty much as much as you want. If you're in the main view where the mouse wheel scrolls photos up and down you can hold Ctrl (Cmd?) to zoom instead.

Replacing does make it sound weird though: "Germany's world bank robbers suffer multiple gun wounds after being hit by bullet"

Als schüchterner neuer Deutscher habe ich mich nicht vertraut. Trotzdem jetzt gepostet, Danke! :)

Hi, those points are certainly valid and I have nothing against these picks!

I just wanted to chime in that perf might not be as big of a problem as you might expect. 5k/hour is 1.4/sec, which sqlite should for sure be able to handle.

In fact, you can do hundreds to thousands of writes/sec, as long as you batch them in transactions (as by default each query is executed in its own transaction).

Hey thanks! The Immich folks are doing an astounding job indeed :)

Depends on what you mean by sharing, but if you put all your photos on a local NAS and run this on it for example, then everyone with access to it would be able to see them through a browser.

There's no explicit sharing feature though.

There's an easy solution to that problem: grab a camera and get crackin'! 😁

Hmm, it seems to work for me. Which Android/Firefox version do you have?

Oops, you're right! I had something there and deleted it before posting :)

Added a short sentence now, thanks for the heads up!

I don't know a lot about fastcgi, but looking it up it seems like it also keeps a persistent process running to avoid execution overhead, but I don't know how that process is managed 🤷‍♂️

Either way, you could use a supervisor of sorts that shuts down the process/container after some idle time (at least for containers I know some exist) and that should probably work fine (outside of interrupting scanning operations).

I haven't tried it myself yet though :)

Vielleicht ist die Tür nicht dafür geeignet, aber ich hab's schon mit drei verschieden erfolgreich gemacht. Es sieht immer hoffnungslos, aber nach 10-60 min findest du schon den richtigen Winkel, vllt dieses Video hilft: https://youtu.be/3VBHxC6H_gY

Versuche auch mit mehr Druck am verschieden Stellen, die Karte ist meistens dann ziemlich kaputt

Ha, hiring only account managers 😅 It does have search and maps, but they are a bit rudimentary right now. Also I have to find some sample geolocated photos to put in the demo, it doesn't have any right now.

Thanks for trying it out! Let me know if you run into any issues or have some ideas :)

No concrete plans for auth yet, but there's an feature request for this. I didn't really want to give a sense of false security with a half-baked solution.

For uploading, I thought about it briefly and it could be interesting. How would you expect it to work?

I imagine you would configure a sort of a target folder structure, then it would dump all uploads based in that structure? Or fully managed like GPhotos/Immich where the app hashes, dedupes and owns the files directly? 🤔

There's probably no alternative as polished as that, but it's not too far off either. You can kinda search like that with photofield (disclaimer: I made it), but many other foss photo libraries also support semantic search by now, LibrePhotos for one.

As already stated it's less about the facts being communicated and more about the way they're being communicated.

I would posit that the mismatch in the style of communication lead to you needing more time to clue in. And in that way, the initial feedback might have been an inefficient way to relay the point.

However it's also entirely possible that trying to package it in a better way, the point of the feedback-giver would have gotten lost, leading you not to clue in at all.

Communication is hard, especially tailoring it to the expected audience. That being said I don't think being an asshole is ever ok, unless it directly saves lives or something. 😅

Ah cool! Maybe the server broke for a sec? 🤷‍♂️