Being real, this is pretty much the only form of piracy I don't support.
But, yeah, you're just not finding them. I know a couple of people that prefer a less polished erotic material, including the range of body types that can loosely be called average.
They have said that there's no good way to search for it, so you have to go for "amateur" and sift through results.
Part of that though, is that anyone trying to earn money off OF are going to polish their product. Great cameras are expensive, but good makeup and lighting aren't, and they go a long way to presenting a person at their best rather than just whatever a random selfie might achieve. So, as much as I despise "rating" people, on only fans you're going to see whatever you think a 5 is making product where they look like a 7 by whatever arbitrary standard is in play.
Plus, since it takes both confidence and the willingness to put oneself out there, OF models self select for people that at least look good on camera. You're not going to run into as many "plain" looks as you would out here in meat space.
There's no tags for that kind of thing, no way to really know ahead of time if a given model is going to fit your idea of average or not. You gotta just sort through it.
That's actually true of anything where the terms you'd use to look it up are super common in multiple contexts, you just have to cast a wide net and winnow out
Don't be a dick. Sex workers deserve a fair wage too.
save