I'm an Emily kind of guy. Abby's a close second.

Leah for the difficulty, Abigail is my usual

I usually romance Leah because I like her vibe, and I appreciate how easy it is to just give her foraged items

Penny. She seems sad about her situation with her mom, and then becomes happy after moving to the farm.

I think I've romanced Maru and Abigail the most often

Shane - I really like him, even his messy room. He resonates with me overcoming his issues, and I like what he says. He's very sweet and kind!

Plus he moves his chicken to your farm and sometimes he hugs it - I'm a sucker to NPCs that love animals.

In my first playthrough I choose Leah and I still think that was a solid choice. But I never setteled on one partner.

Currently I try or rather plan to romance Penny.

Alex.

I’m a trans woman with a problematic attraction to any man who would’ve bullied me in high school.

Before you ask—yes, I am aware this is the only reason anybody ever marries Alex.

Penny. I appreciate that she is a good person from the get-go, even if her attempts to be nice can sometimes put others out (we’ve all made mistakes with the best intentions). I feel like her romance plot improves her life the most if any of the villagers, though I do wish she had more to do after marriage. She wants to get out of Pam’s trailer, only to hang around the farmhouse all day instead?

Abigail or Krobus

No one. Ace/aro in all things.

Sebastian, every time. I have attempted others, but I always come back. I guess emo twink that plays D&D is just my type.

Leah or Penny. Both have personalities that match my current partner.

I’ve put quite some hours into the game but haven’t pursued anyone romantically yet. Do they help on the farm if you partner up?

Harvey. I picked up the game during the covid lockdown and I guess "wash your hands" is my love language, lol.

Polygamy mod with abi and Leah. Can't split them up.

If going the mod route probably Sophia too

I spend all my time down in the mines/dungeon. Ain't got time for love.

Haley and mommy <3

I try to go with a different person each time, but I like Abigail the most

I'm still working my way through experiencing all the romances I'd like to. But for some reason I often marry Haley. I am not romantically interested in women. ??? I know I'll pursue them in games anyways to see the story bits, to learn more about them, but I have already seen the story and learned more so not sure why I do this. Pretty sure it is not a case of secret closet for various reasons that are probably off-topic to Stardew Valley.

Mary, she's just generally the most happy to live her life still and yet ecstatic to be living with you as well. It seems like the most wholesome relationship imo.

*Maru, phone auto corrected and I didn't notice

By now, I feel weird going for those that feel barely out if their teens. I like Leah and Elliot. I love creative types and those who work hard to pursue their passions, even in the face of adversity. I also like that they still pursue their passions when they live with me. Others have felt kind of empty after moving to my farm. One time I chose Krobus over marriage, no regrets there either.

On my first playthrough. I'm in year 6 and just about ready to start doing Qi quests once I finish off perfection. Haven't romanced anyone yet. Thinking about either Leah, Penny, or Abigail.

Interestingly, the first accessory I picked up was a "Perfect Ice Rod," so combat has been easy since that. I have a big stone chest that is about ¾ full of all the accessories, but only one Level 3 Parrot Egg.

Abigail was tailor made to bait me into playing the game, to be honest

Penny is usually my choice though I consider Abigail and leah too.

She comes from an impoverished broken home with that thing as a mom, but still tries to be a better version of herself and enrich the lives of local kids. She's bookish and likes the library. Also isnt picky about common gifts.

Quiet, shy, kind, humble and intelligent. Green flags all around. As a bonus she has some actual assets in the picture even if they're only little b or c-cups. half the girl portraits I can't tell what they got going on body wise.

Krobus. But we're just roommates ;)