Vegan Burgers Just Beat Beef in Germany’s Most Respected Consumer Test

3 months ago by Shailu45 to c/vegan

The “vegan is expensive and tastes bad” argument has had a rough time lately
starchylemming 43 points 3 months ago

mmmm exactly what i want in my burger "Antibiotic-resistant bacteria were found in 40% of the beef patties tested. One contained genuinely pathogenic bacteria. The vegan patties? Zero contaminants."

path: 0 24080481, hotness: undefined, score: 43, children: 5
Captain_Buddha 4 points 3 months ago

^where was this quote from? I didn't see that in this article.

path: 0 24080481 24082160, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 2
starchylemming 5 points 3 months ago
path: 0 24080481 24082160 24082261, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 1
Captain_Buddha 3 points 3 months ago

Thanks!

path: 0 24080481 24082160 24082261 24095861, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
FatVegan 1 point 3 months ago

I just want fat and off putting smell in my burger

path: 0 24080481 24100781, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
Amnesigenic 0 points 3 months ago

Zero contaminants in a highly processed food tells me that the processing facility is maintained better, unrelated to flavor

path: 0 24080481 24102811, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 0
dragospirvu75 10 points 3 months ago

Great news for vegan community. I hope other countries will do the same.

path: 0 24085305, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 0
ShotDonkey 5 points 3 months ago

"Some beef patties, meanwhile, showed up with off-putting smells, flat flavors, and shelf-life issues."

Hmm, I really wonder why 💁

path: 0 24099043, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 1
Amnesigenic 1 point 3 months ago

A better shelf life is cool but has absolutely nothing to do with actually tasting better

path: 0 24099043 24102799, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
geneva_convenience 5 points 3 months ago

Was it a head to head comparison? The article looks a bit out of context

path: 0 24083445, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 8
Ephera 14 points 3 months ago

Generally, how these Stiftung Warentest tests work is that they a pick a product category, like here patties, then they come up with disciplines to rate them in and then they grade each product accordingly.
Some of the disciplines here were (translated by me):

  • sensory rating
  • nutritional-physiological quality
  • microbiological quality
  • user friendliness of packaging

I would assume that they did a blind taste test and all that jazz, too. It is their business model to sell the data to industry, investors etc., so if their methodology wasn't up to snuff, they'd be out of business pretty quickly.

path: 0 24083445 24083781, hotness: undefined, score: 14, children: 6
geneva_convenience 2 points 3 months ago

The article is totally unsupported by the test then as it says it is only about taste.

path: 0 24083445 24083781 24088560, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 1
Ephera 11 points 3 months ago

I am very confused. Are we seeing same article? @Captain_Buddha@lemmy.world below also seemed to not see a direct quote from the article.

Here's the part of the article describing the results that I see:

The result

Vegan patties came out on top, and it wasn’t particularly close:

  1. Overall rating

    Seven out of ten plant-based patties rated “good.” Only three out of ten beef patties did.

    The three top-scoring burgers came from Aldi MyVay, Garden Gourmet, and Beyond — and they were all vegan.

    This is a dramatic reversal from the last time this test was run in 2021, when meat still held the edge. The improvement in plant-based products over just a few years has been remarkable.

  2. Fats

    Vegan patties averaged 43% less fat and 20% fewer calories than their beef counterparts — and the fat they do contain skews toward the healthy, unsaturated kind, while beef patties lean heavily on saturated fat.

  3. Taste

    Plant-based options scored better on average for seasoning, juiciness, and overall cooking results. Some beef patties, meanwhile, showed up with off-putting smells, flat flavors, and shelf-life issues.

  4. Food safety

    Antibiotic-resistant bacteria were found in 40% of the beef patties tested. One contained genuinely pathogenic bacteria. The vegan patties? Zero contaminants.

  5. Price

    The vegan patties were, on average, 20% cheaper than beef. And that’s before accounting for the massive government subsidies that artificially deflate the price of conventional meat. Without those subsidies, the gap would be even wider.

path: 0 24083445 24083781 24088560 24089649, hotness: undefined, score: 11, children: 0
ColeSloth 0 points 3 months ago

So would have completely lost in a test based on "what tastes best".

path: 0 24083445 24083781 24088178, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 3
Ephera 7 points 3 months ago

There might be an issue with not everyone seeing the same article text. Here's what it says for taste:

Plant-based options scored better on average for seasoning, juiciness, and overall cooking results. Some beef patties, meanwhile, showed up with off-putting smells, flat flavors, and shelf-life issues.

The original source lists more rating categories and the source we're getting it from is biased, so maybe some taste categories with opposite results are left out here.

But it can't be too biased either, though, because the original publication from Stiftung Warentest is also titled "Vegan beats Beef" ("Vegan schlägt Rind­fleisch"). They would not write that, if it misrepresented their data.

path: 0 24083445 24083781 24088178 24089942, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 2
ColeSloth -1 points 3 months ago

That definitely sounds like a rigged test. Lol. "Vegan burger is better than beef... Made with rancid meat"

path: 0 24083445 24083781 24088178 24089942 24092626, hotness: undefined, score: -1, children: 1
SloppilyFloss 7 points 3 months ago path: 0 24083445 24083506, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 0
zod000 3 points 3 months ago

The big thing to consider is that this is comparing the vegan burgers against the pre-made frozen patties, which is probably the only way to do it. I have always considered those pre-made patties pretty "meh" so it doesn't surprise me at all that impossible or beyond can beat them. My daughter is a vegetarian so we buy the impossible beef fairly often, and it is the only brand I've tried that is actually very close to actual beef. I've made chili and "meat" sauce with it and it comes out quite fine.

I had always said that if they could get the price lower than actual beef they'd likely so really well. I just hadn't anticipated that happening because beef prices went through the roof.

IMO none of the vegan brands are as good tasting as higher quality fresh ground beef from a meat department or butcher, but some are easily a match for any of the boxed frozen patties.

path: 0 24104871, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 1
lemonwood 1 point 3 months ago

That's an unfair comparison. Here's how to make it fair: The department stores and local stores could easily use peas instead of meat and it would improve the taste. Since vegan burger patties already have the edge when frozen, they surely would be even better when fresh. The stores just have to up their game and learn how to do it.

path: 0 24104871 24112673, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
SystemDisc 2 points 3 months ago

Mmm, beet beef

(I read it as Vegan Burgers Are Just Beet Beef at first glance lol)

path: 0 24095000, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
NostraDavid 2 points 3 months ago

Seven out of ten plant-based patties rated “good.”

Good in what?

I looked at the page of the original study (locked behind a paywall, sadly), and the indications seem positive. I guess I'll have to find a good-quality vegan patty soon enough. I'm very sceptical of "vegan beef" being a tasty replacement, but we'll see.

path: 0 24100948, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 1
FatVegan 3 points 3 months ago

Vegan patties are a bit of a mixed bag. Don't get discouraged by not liking one. If you like burger king, try beyond burger. It's been a long time aince i ate meat, but that's exactly what i remember the taste like. If the patty is really cheap and looks "compressed" and has not much rexture, maybe atay away. I mean maybe you like it but damn, for me it's rough. Beyond beef also has minced meat now, which my girlfriend doesn't like because it tastes too much like beef.

I think going in expecring exactly what you are used roo is the wrong approach. We are creatures of habit, and sometimes it takes some time to break that habit. My nephew is a really picky eater and since he knows i don't eat meat, he's always sceptic. Once i made him nuggets and he was like: what are these? Not chicken i assume. I told him no, they are not chicken, they are from a cuban bird, he never ate, so he ate it and loved it. Which is in a way kind of sick, knowing he wouldn't have eaten them if he knew it wasn't some random animal, instead of something else. Like i don't miss meat at all, but even if i could pick now a good vegan burger and a good normal burger without it being problematic or whatnot, i would pick the vegan burger every time. It's also way easier to prepare, and way harder to fuck up, they are just always juicier.

path: 0 24100948 24102291, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
Tenderizer78 2 points 3 months ago

The beef in burgers is never really important to the taste, other than the fact that it's savoury. Mushrooms could just as easily fill the role (texture aside).

path: 0 24099156, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 4
NostraDavid 3 points 3 months ago

Throw some algae in there, and you've got a stew going!

path: 0 24099156 24100852, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
Amnesigenic -2 points 3 months ago

Dead wrong

path: 0 24099156 24102134, hotness: undefined, score: -2, children: 2
jerkface 5 points 3 months ago

Murder is wrong.

path: 0 24099156 24102134 24102218, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 1
Amnesigenic 5 points 3 months ago

Correct, but completely unrelated to the claims presented here

path: 0 24099156 24102134 24102218 24102251, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 0
anyhow2503 2 points 3 months ago

I can't see any issues with their methodology or selection of samples. I'm not even that surprised about the outcome. What I think should be kept in mind however, is that the quality of ground beef in pre-formed patties is generally abysmal (at least in Germany, where this test was conducted). Using packaged ground beef to form the patties yourself is only marginally better. A burger made from freshly ground beef that can be served medium-rare and doesn't need to be cooked through because of food safety reasons, like all the other options, is on a completely different level.

Making burgers from pre-formed patties is a waste of resources in my opinion and ground beef from the supermarket is better used for other dishes where it's not the main feature and can be stretched across more portions. The results of this test can only be a good thing and if I get the desire for a home-cooked burger, I'll probably use plant based patties.

path: 0 24083494, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
curiousaur 0 points 3 months ago

At what point do these ultra processed foods become worse for our health than meat though? I love impossible burgers, they taste impossibly delicious so much so that I'm suspicious it's really bad for me.

path: 0 24088801, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 2
markstos 14 points 3 months ago

The Impossible burger isn’t trying to be healthier than beans and rice, but even as a processed food it’s healthier than a meat burger.

As reported in this study, the plant-based options had less fat and fewer calories. They would also have no cholesterol, which is only found in animals foods, and they may contain some fiber, which is only found in plant foods. A number of processed meats have been food to be carcinogenic while I don’t think any plant-based burgers have.

The book How Not To Die reviews scientific studies of food choices if you want a deeper dive.. finding animal-based protein is correlated with a range of diseases.

So no, I don’t expect veggie burgers will be less healthy than meat patties.

path: 0 24088801 24090586, hotness: undefined, score: 14, children: 0
farting_gorilla 8 points 3 months ago

Dr Gregor has a good series on this, basically yes, these mock meats are not "healthy", but they are healthier than animal meat. On nutrition facts, search for "ultraprocessed".
Here is a good one about this:
https://nutritionfacts.org/...

path: 0 24088801 24099007, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 0
ShinkanTrain 0 points 2 months ago

Completely unsurprising that they beat the frozen cow anuses they try to pass as burgers tbh

path: 0 24113029, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 0
snugglesthefalse -5 points 3 months ago

Why are they trying to be fake meat anyway? Vegan substitutes rarely compare quite as well but honestly they'd be way better if they stopped trying to imitate something they're not and did more to stand up on their own. All the good vegan food I've had was just being its own thing.

path: 0 24091783, hotness: undefined, score: -5, children: 1
Ephera 3 points 3 months ago

I imagine, they mainly don't want to compete with the plethora of cheap+good vegan protein options: lentils, beans, chickpeas, nuts, tofu, tempeh, seitan, TVP, hummus, falafel etc.

Faking meat works as a market, because folks often just want what they're used to, and then you're primarily competing against real meat, which is much more expensive, so you can excuse quite a large profit margin.

path: 0 24091783 24098925, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
makeshift0546 -31 points 3 months ago

Horse shit.

Look I've reduced my meat intake and have no issues with vegans. And I'm certainly not reading up on this. But their ain't no fucking way a vegan burger beat a burger in a fair contest.

I feel like this shit is counter productive. People hear shit like this and just toss it into the 'liburl lie pile' mentally.

path: 0 24082584, hotness: undefined, score: -31, children: 17
SloppilyFloss 18 points 3 months ago

And I'm certainly not reading up on this.

Then why comment that this is horse shit?

path: 0 24082584 24082788, hotness: undefined, score: 18, children: 5
makeshift0546 -26 points 3 months ago

Because anyone who has ever liked the taste of a hamburger knows it's immediately bullshit.

And I'm not spending time understanding how it's bullshit.

path: 0 24082584 24082788 24082845, hotness: undefined, score: -26, children: 4
SloppilyFloss 15 points 3 months ago

As far as I can tell, the report is based on the evaluation of five trained testers. So at the very least these five people, who aren't even vegan since they had to test the beef patties, decided that they liked the vegan patties more than the beef patties.

Five people is not a lot, sure, but it's more convincing than your comment that it's bullshit just because.

And I'm not spending time understanding how it's bullshit.

Again, then why comment?

path: 0 24082584 24082788 24082845 24083290, hotness: undefined, score: 15, children: 0
jerkface 9 points 3 months ago

The question was, "Why did you comment?" not, "Generally tell us about your damage."

path: 0 24082584 24082788 24082845 24087574, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 0
ShotDonkey 5 points 3 months ago

Coming from a carnivor upbringing (can't call it differently), where both parents were hunters and we had the best meat you can possibly imagine both in terms of ethics and taste 7 days a week... I can tell you, the vegan burgers are absolutely impressive and I choose them now over meat, as they are on par taste wise and for a variety of other reasons (price etc).

path: 0 24082584 24082788 24082845 24099162, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 0
Herr_S_aus_H 5 points 3 months ago

Your taste is just this, your taste. People have other taste then you.
On top of that, taste is only one aspect of this consumer test and yet still, the plant based patties have on average scored better in taste then the beef patties

path: 0 24082584 24082788 24082845 24083359, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 0
NewOldGuard 13 points 3 months ago

You're the only one here reflexively tossing it in the "liberal lie pile," and even proudly standing by your ignorance by refusing to engage with the source.

path: 0 24082584 24084877, hotness: undefined, score: 13, children: 0
jerkface 11 points 3 months ago

Kindly go cope somewhere else. This clearly isn't for you.

"I'm too fragile to read the article but too triggered to keep my mouth shut." Just fuck off.

path: 0 24082584 24087188, hotness: undefined, score: 11, children: 0
HiddenLayer555 8 points 3 months ago

Has it ever occurred to you that some people genuinely don't like the taste of meat and think plants taste better?

path: 0 24082584 24098914, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 6
melsaskca 2 points 3 months ago

Aren't they trying to make plants taste like meat? I'm not sure what you mean.

path: 0 24082584 24098914 24101974, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Amnesigenic -1 points 3 months ago

Has it occured to you that bringing up people who hate the taste of meat in a discussion about whether or not vegan burgers taste better than real meat is completely fucking moronic?

path: 0 24082584 24098914 24102212, hotness: undefined, score: -1, children: 0
makeshift0546 -3 points 3 months ago

👌👍 5 of 5 people is definitely representing the population. I'm SURE you could recreate that result with a representative population 🤣

Y'all are so butthurt I pointed out the absurdity of this result.

path: 0 24082584 24098914 24100353, hotness: undefined, score: -3, children: 3
jerkface 2 points 3 months ago

Get banned, child. I know, you don't read the article, and you don't read the fucking rules, do you? You're coming here just to be an asshole and vent your hurt feelings. Fuck is wrong with you? GTFO.

path: 0 24082584 24098914 24100353 24101848, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 2
makeshift0546 0 points 3 months ago

👍

path: 0 24082584 24098914 24100353 24101848 24111161, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 0
Amnesigenic -3 points 3 months ago

They're right, cry about it

path: 0 24082584 24098914 24100353 24101848 24102219, hotness: undefined, score: -3, children: 0
jumponboard 4 points 3 months ago

I get your disbelieve but you have to look at what they did. They tested convenience food, not self made quality products. They compared meat products to plant based counterfits. The good stuff is actually whole food that you can make yourself. You can't compare a raw beef with a raw lentil patty since they taste completely different. But you can make an incredibly delicious lentil burger that is also very healthy and eco friendly. It all comes down to the recipe. As soon as you add seasoning, good meat doesn't neccessarily win always for meat eaters.

path: 0 24082584 24083613, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 1
jerkface 2 points 3 months ago

you have to look at what they did

That is specifically what he is choosing not to do.

path: 0 24082584 24083613 24101907, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
vegan
vegan

@lemmy.ml

login for more options
3621
330
50

An online space for the vegans of Lemmy.

Rules and miscellaneous:

  1. We take for granted that if you engage in this community, you understand that veganism is about the animals. You either are vegan for the animals, or you are not (this is not to say that discussions about climate/environment/health are not allowed, of course)
  2. No omni/carnist apologists. This is not a place where to ask to be hand-holded into veganims. Omnis coddling/backpatting is not tolerated, nor are /r/DebateAVegan-like threads
  3. Use content warnings and NSFW tags for triggering content
  4. Circlejerking belongs to /c/vegancirclejerk
  5. All posts should abide by Lemmy's Code of Conduct

go to feed...