Black Mirror AI

a year ago by fossilesque to c/science_memes

Catoblepas 424 points a year ago

Funny that they’re calling them AI haters when they’re specifically poisoning AI that ignores the do not enter sign. FAFO.

path: 0 17251597, hotness: undefined, score: 424, children: 6
caseyweederman 50 points a year ago

First Albatross, First Out

path: 0 17251597 17256247, hotness: undefined, score: 50, children: 1
Naich 22 points a year ago

Fluffy Animal's Fecal Orifice.

path: 0 17251597 17256247 17258517, hotness: undefined, score: 22, children: 0
Clanket 16 points a year ago

Fair As Fuck Ok?

path: 0 17251597 17259255, hotness: undefined, score: 16, children: 0
Stupidmanager 12 points a year ago

Sheesh people, it’s “fuck around and find out”. Probably more appropriate in the leopards eating face context but this works enough.

path: 0 17251597 17261843, hotness: undefined, score: 12, children: 2
tatterdemalion 10 points a year ago

What are you talking about? FAFO obviously stands for "fill asshole full of". Like FAFO dicks. Or FAFO pennies.

path: 0 17251597 17261843 17269814, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 0
Gismonda 3 points a year ago

I’m glad you’re here to tell us these things!

path: 0 17251597 17261843 17266165, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
passepartout 262 points a year ago

AI is the "most aggressive" example of "technologies that are not done 'for us' but 'to us.'"

Well said.

path: 0 17252476, hotness: undefined, score: 262, children: 0
Natanox 198 points a year ago

Deployment of Nepenthes and also Anubis (both described as "the nuclear option") are not hate. It's self-defense against pure selfish evil, projects are being sucked dry and some like ScummVM could only freakin' survive thanks to these tools.

Those AI companies and data scrapers/broker companies shall perish, and whoever wrote this headline at arstechnica shall step on Lego each morning for the next 6 months.

path: 0 17253369, hotness: undefined, score: 198, children: 8
faythofdragons 52 points a year ago

Feels good to be on an instance with Anubis

path: 0 17253369 17254352, hotness: undefined, score: 52, children: 0
pewgar_seemsimandroid 42 points a year ago

one of the united Nations websites deployed Anubis

path: 0 17253369 17253919, hotness: undefined, score: 42, children: 0
chonglibloodsport 26 points a year ago

Do you have a link to a story of what happened to ScummVM? I love that project and I’d be really upset if it was lost!

path: 0 17253369 17254509, hotness: undefined, score: 26, children: 4
Natanox 53 points a year ago path: 0 17253369 17254509 17254544, hotness: undefined, score: 53, children: 3
chonglibloodsport 10 points a year ago

Thank you!

path: 0 17253369 17254509 17254544 17254584, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 0
PolarKraken 8 points a year ago

Thanks, interesting and brief read!

path: 0 17253369 17254509 17254544 17257013, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 0
arararagi 2 points a year ago

Very cool, and the mascot is cute too as a nice bonus.

path: 0 17253369 17254509 17254544 17262518, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Rubisco 1 point a year ago

I love that one is named Nepenthes.

path: 0 17253369 17268414, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
RedSnt 156 points a year ago

It's so sad we're burning coal and oil to generate heat and electricity for dumb shit like this.

path: 0 17254728, hotness: undefined, score: 156, children: 20
rdri 29 points a year ago

Wait till you realize this project's purpose IS to force AI to waste even more resources.

path: 0 17254728 17255240, hotness: undefined, score: 29, children: 6
kuhli 90 points a year ago
path: 0 17254728 17255240 17255924, hotness: undefined, score: 90, children: 3
Aux -17 points a year ago

Here's a thing - it's not useless.

path: 0 17254728 17255240 17255924 17258679, hotness: undefined, score: -17, children: 2
irmoz 9 points a year ago

What use does an AI get out of scraping pages designed to confuse and mislead it?

path: 0 17254728 17255240 17255924 17258679 17262119, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 1
lennivelkant 5 points a year ago

That's war. That has been the nature of war and deterrence policy ever since industrial manufacture has escalated both the scale of deployments and the cost and destructive power of weaponry. Make it too expensive for the other side to continue fighting (or, in the case of deterrence, to even attack in the first place). If the payoff for scraping no longer justifies the investment of power and processing time, maybe the smaller ones will give up and leave you in peace.

path: 0 17254728 17255240 17260026, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 0
Opisek 3 points a year ago

Always say please and thank you to your friendly neighbourhood LLM!

path: 0 17254728 17255240 17270158, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
endeavor 15 points a year ago
path: 0 17254728 17258891, hotness: undefined, score: 15, children: 7
DontMakeMoreBabies 4 points a year ago

Governments are full of two types: (1) the stupid, and (2) the self-interested. The former doesn't understand technology, and the latter doesn't fucking care.

Of course "governments" dropped the ball on regulating AI.

path: 0 17254728 17258891 17272601, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 0
Tja -9 points a year ago

Of all the things governments should regulate, this is probably the least important and ineffective one.

path: 0 17254728 17258891 17261189, hotness: undefined, score: -9, children: 5
irmoz 3 points a year ago

Why?

path: 0 17254728 17258891 17261189 17262122, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 1
Tja 5 points a year ago
  • super hard to tell where electricity for certain computing task is coming from. What if I use 100% renewable for ai training offsetting it by using super cheap dirty electricity for other tasks

  • who will audit what electricity is used for anyway? Any computer will have an government sealed rootkit?

  • offshore

  • a million problems that require more attention, from migration, to Healthcare, to economy

path: 0 17254728 17258891 17261189 17262122 17265861, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 0
endeavor 1 point a year ago
path: 0 17254728 17258891 17261189 17267875, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 2
Tja 1 point a year ago

That's already happening, how do you want the government to legislate against Russian, Chinese or American actors?

path: 0 17254728 17258891 17261189 17267875 17271727, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
MonkeMischief 1 point a year ago

I kinda feel like we're 75% of the way there already, and we gotta be hitting with everything we've got if we're to stand a chance against it...

path: 0 17254728 17258891 17261189 17267875 17268894, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
andybytes 11 points a year ago
path: 0 17254728 17255555, hotness: undefined, score: 11, children: 0
andybytes -1 points a year ago

I mean, we contemplate communism, fascism, this, that, and another. When really, it's just collective trauma and reactionary behavior, because of the lack of self-awareness and in the world around us. So this could just be synthesized as human stupidity. We're killing ourselves because we're too stupid to live.

path: 0 17254728 17255544, hotness: undefined, score: -1, children: 3
newaccountwhodis 8 points a year ago

Dumbest sentiment I read in a while. People, even kids, are pretty much aware of what's happening (remember Fridays for Future?), but the rich have coopted the power apparatus and they are not letting anyone get in their way of destroying the planet to become a little richer.

path: 0 17254728 17255544 17260074, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 0
untorquer 7 points a year ago

Unclear how AI companies destroying the planet's resources and habitability has any relation to a political philosophy seated in trauma and ignorance except maybe the greed of a capitalist CEO's whimsy.

The fact that the powerful are willing to destroy the planet for momentary gain bears no reflection on the intelligence or awareness of the meek.

path: 0 17254728 17255544 17258874, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 0
Swedneck 1 point a year ago

what the fuck does this even mean

path: 0 17254728 17255544 17338263, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
heyWhatsay 99 points a year ago

This might explain why newer AI models are going nuts. Good jorb 👍

path: 0 17251621, hotness: undefined, score: 99, children: 8
pennomi 30 points a year ago
path: 0 17251621 17255208, hotness: undefined, score: 30, children: 0
Eyekaytee 11 points a year ago

what models are going nuts?

path: 0 17251621 17253803, hotness: undefined, score: 11, children: 6
heyWhatsay 2 points a year ago

Claude version 4, the openAi mini models, not sure what else

path: 0 17251621 17253803 17265648, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Vari 2 points a year ago

Not sure if OP can provide sources, but it makes sense kinda? Like AI has been trained on just about every human creation to get it this far, what happens when the only new training data is AI slop?

path: 0 17251621 17253803 17255883, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 4
Aux -5 points a year ago

AI being trained by AI is how you train most models. Man, people here are ridiculously ignorant...

path: 0 17251621 17253803 17255883 17258784, hotness: undefined, score: -5, children: 3
irmoz 4 points a year ago

They specifically said "slop". Maybe you breezed straight past that word in your fury.

path: 0 17251621 17253803 17255883 17258784 17262147, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 2
NaibofTabr 84 points a year ago path: 0 17252708, hotness: undefined, score: 84, children: 2
MadMadBunny 11 points a year ago

Thank you!!

path: 0 17252708 17253721, hotness: undefined, score: 11, children: 0
sad_detective_man 10 points a year ago

thanks for the links. the more I read of this the more based it is

path: 0 17252708 17254647, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 0
ininewcrow 76 points a year ago

Nice ..... I look forward to the next generation of AI counter counter measures that will make the internet an even more unbearable mess in order to funnel as much money and control to a small set of idiots that think they can become masters of the universe and own every single penny on the planet.

path: 0 17252065, hotness: undefined, score: 76, children: 31
IndiBrony 47 points a year ago

All the while as we roast to death because all of this will take more resources than the entire energy output of a medium sized country.

path: 0 17252065 17252768, hotness: undefined, score: 47, children: 28
DeathsEmbrace 8 points a year ago
path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253073, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 1
explodicle 9 points a year ago

It is already!

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253073 17255156, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 0
vivendi 2 points a year ago

I will cite the scientific article later when I find it, but essentially you're wrong.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 9
lipilee 8 points a year ago

water != energy, but i'm actually here for the science if you happen to find it.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257881, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 2
EldritchFeminity 3 points a year ago

It can in the sense that many forms of generating power are just some form of water or steam turbine, but that's neither here nor there.

IMO, the graph is misleading anyway because the criticism of AI from that perspective was the data centers and companies using water for cooling and energy, not individuals using water on an individual prompt. I mean, Microsoft has entered a deal with a power company to restart one of the nuclear reactors on Three Mile Island in order to compensate for the expected cost in energy of their AI. Using their service is bad because it incentivizes their use of so much energy/resources.

It's like how during COVID the world massively reduced the individual usage of cars for a year and emissions barely budged. Because a single one of the largest freight ships puts out more emissions than every personal car combined annually.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257881 17263580, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
vivendi 1 point a year ago

This particular graph is because a lot of people freaked out over "AI draining oceans" that's why the original paper (I'll look for it when I have time, I have a exam tomorrow. Fucking higher ed man) made this graph

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257881 17257943, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
xthexder 6 points a year ago

Asking ChatGPT a question doesn't take 1 hour like most of these... this is a very misleading graph

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257828, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 3
vivendi 5 points a year ago

This is actually misleading in the other direction: ChatGPT is a particularly intensive model. You can run a GPT-4o class model on a consumer mid to high end GPU which would then use something in the ballpark of gaming in terms of environmental impact.

You can also run a cluster of 3090s or 4090s to train the model, which is what people do actually, in which case it's still in the same range as gaming. (And more productive than 8 hours of WoW grind while chugging a warmed up Nutella glass as a drink).

Models like Google's Gemma (NOT Gemini these are two completely different things) are insanely power efficient.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257828 17257862, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 2
Sorse 1 point a year ago

What about training an AI?

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257922, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 1
vivendi 4 points a year ago

According to https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21015

The absolute most monstrous, energy guzzling model tested needed 10 MW of power to train.

Most models need less than that, and non-frontier models can even be trained on gaming hardware with comparatively little energy consumption.

That paper by the way says there is a 2.4x increase YoY for model training compute, BUT that paper doesn't mention DeepSeek, which rocked the western AI world with comparatively little training cost (2.7 M GPU Hours in total)

Some companies offset their model training environmental damage with renewable and whatever bullshit, so the actual daily usage cost is more important than the huge cost at the start (Drop by drop is an ocean formed - Persian proverb)

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17257074 17257922 17258069, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 0
Eyekaytee -11 points a year ago

we’re rolling out renewables at like 100x the rate of ai electricity use, so no need to worry there

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17254056, hotness: undefined, score: -11, children: 5
Serinus 9 points a year ago

Yeah, at this rate we'll be just fine. (As long as this is still the Reagan administration.)

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17254056 17254257, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 4
Eyekaytee 2 points a year ago

yep the biggest worry isn't AI, it's India

https://www.worldometers.info/...

The west is lowering its co2 output while India is slurping up all the co2 we're saving:

This doesn't include China of course, the most egregious of the co2 emitters

AI is not even a tiny blip on that radar, especially as AI is in data centres and devices which runs on electricity so the more your country goes to renewables the less co2 impacting it is over time

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17254056 17254257 17254526, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 3
Zozano -14 points a year ago

I've been thinking about this for a while. Consider how quick LLM's are.

If the amount of energy spent powering your device (without an LLM), is more than using an LLM, then it's probably saving energy.

In all honesty, I've probably saved over 50 hours or more since I started using it about 2 months ago.

Coding has become incredibly efficient, and I'm not suffering through search-engine hell any more.

Edit:

Lemmy when someone uses AI to get a cheap, fast answer: “Noooo, it’s killing the planet!”

Lemmy when someone uses a nuclear reactor to run Doom: Dark Ages on a $20,000 RGB space heater: “Based”

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253407, hotness: undefined, score: -14, children: 9
xthexder 2 points a year ago

Just writing code uses almost no energy. Your PC should be clocking down when you're not doing anything. 1GHz is plenty for text editing.

Does ChatGPT (or whatever LLM you use) reduce the number of times you hit build? Because that's where all the electricity goes.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253407 17257861, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 6
Zozano 4 points a year ago

Except that half the time I dont know what the fuck I'm doing. It's normal for me to spend hours trying to figure out why a small config file isnt working.

That's not just text editing, that's browsing the internet, referring to YouTube videos, or wallowing in self-pity.

That was before I started using gpt.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253407 17257861 17257973, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 2
Aux 2 points a year ago

What kind of code are you writing that your CPU goes to sleep? If you follow any good practices like TDD, atomic commits, etc, and your code base is larger than hello world, your PC will be running at its peak quite a lot.

Example: linting on every commit + TDD. You'll be making loads of commits every day, linting a decent code base will definitely push your CPU to 100% for a few seconds. Running tests, even with caches, will push CPU to 100% for a few minutes. Plus compilation for running the app, some apps take hours to compile.

In general, text editing is a small part of the developer workflow. Only junior devs spend a lot of time typing stuff.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253407 17257861 17258881, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 2
ryannathans 2 points a year ago

Are you using your PC less hours per day?

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253407 17253455, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 1
Zozano 2 points a year ago

Yep, more time for doing home renovations.

path: 0 17252065 17252768 17253407 17253455 17253547, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Prox 4 points a year ago

We're racing towards the Blackwall from Cyberpunk 2077...

path: 0 17252065 17255930, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 1
barsoap -1 points a year ago

Already there. The blackwall is AI-powered and Markov chains are most definitely an AI technique.

path: 0 17252065 17255930 17256456, hotness: undefined, score: -1, children: 0
Vari 70 points a year ago

I’m so happy to see that ai poison is a thing

path: 0 17255869, hotness: undefined, score: 70, children: 3
ricdeh 14 points a year ago

Don't be too happy. For every such attempt there are countless highly technical papers on how to filter out the poisoning, and they are very effective. As the other commenter said, this is an arms race.

path: 0 17255869 17259138, hotness: undefined, score: 14, children: 2
arararagi 6 points a year ago

So we should just give up? Surely you don't mean that.

path: 0 17255869 17259138 17262405, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 1
MonkeMischief 3 points a year ago

I don't think they meant that. Probably more like

"Don't upload all your precious data carelessly thinking it's un-stealable just because of this one countermeasure."

Which of course, really sucks for artists.

path: 0 17255869 17259138 17262405 17268871, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
Zacryon 59 points a year ago

I suppose this will become an arms race, just like with ad-blockers and ad-blocker detection/circumvention measures.
There will be solutions for scraper-blockers/traps. Then those become more sophisticated. Then the scrapers become better again and so on.

I don't really see an end to this madness. Such a huge waste of resources.

path: 0 17258059, hotness: undefined, score: 59, children: 7
pyre 25 points a year ago

there is an end: you legislate it out of existence. unfortunately the US politicians instead are trying to outlaw any regulations regarding AI instead. I'm sure it's not about the money.

path: 0 17258059 17258925, hotness: undefined, score: 25, children: 0
enbiousenvy 13 points a year ago

the rise of LLM companies scraping internet is also, I noticed, the moment YouTube is going harsher against adblockers or 3rd party viewer.

Piped or Invidious instances that I used to use are no longer works, did so may other instances. NewPipe have been broken more frequently. youtube-dl or yt-dlp sometimes cannot fetch higher resolution video. and so sometimes the main youtube side is broken on Firefox with ublock origin.

Not just youtube but also z-library, and especially sci-hub & libgen also have been harder to use sometimes.

path: 0 17258059 17260982, hotness: undefined, score: 13, children: 0
arararagi 10 points a year ago

Well, the adblockers are still wining, even on twitch where the ads como from the same pipeline as the stream, people made solutions that still block them since ublock origin couldn't by itself.

path: 0 17258059 17262371, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 2
JayGray91 2 points a year ago

What do you use to block twitch ads? With UBO I still get the occasional ad marathon

path: 0 17258059 17262371 17280474, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 1
arararagi 2 points a year ago path: 0 17258059 17262371 17280474 17280888, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
glibg 3 points a year ago

Madness is right. If only we didn't have to create these things to generate dollar.

path: 0 17258059 17258476, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 1
MonkeMischief 2 points a year ago

I feel like the down-vote squad misunderstood you here.

I think I agree: If people made software they actually wanted , for human people , and less for the incentive of "easiest way to automate generation of dollarinos." I think we'd see a lot less sophistication and effort being put into such stupid things.

These things are made by the greedy, or by employees of the greedy. Not everyone working on this stuff is an exploited wagie, but also this nonsense-ware is where "market demand" currently is.

Ever since the Internet put on a suit and tie and everything became abou real-life money-sploitz, even malware is boring anymore.

New dangerous exploit? 99% chance it's just another twist on a crypto-miner or ransomware.

path: 0 17258059 17258476 17268756, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Wilco 49 points a year ago

Could you imagine a world where word of mouth became the norm again? Your friends would tell you about websites, and those sites would never show on search results because crawlers get stuck.

path: 0 17254504, hotness: undefined, score: 49, children: 18
Zexks 21 points a year ago

No they wouldn't. I'm guessing you're not old enough to remember a time before search engines. The public web dies without crawling. Corporations will own it all you'll never hear about anything other than amazon or Walmart dot com again.

path: 0 17254504 17254972, hotness: undefined, score: 21, children: 8
Wilco 29 points a year ago

Nope. That isn't how it worked. You joined message boards that had lists of web links. There were still search engines, but they were pretty localized. Google was also amazing when their slogan was "don't be evil" and they meant it.

path: 0 17254504 17254972 17255570, hotness: undefined, score: 29, children: 7
zanyllama52 21 points a year ago

I was there. People carried physical notepads with URLs, shared them on BBS', or other forums. It was wild.

path: 0 17254504 17254972 17255570 17255794, hotness: undefined, score: 21, children: 3
i_love_FFT 16 points a year ago

There was also "circle banners" of websites that would link to each others... And then off course "stumble upon"...

path: 0 17254504 17254972 17255570 17255794 17255859, hotness: undefined, score: 16, children: 2
Zexks 0 points a year ago

No. Only very selective people joined message boards. The rest were on AOL, compact or not at all. You're taking a very select group of.people and expecting the Facebook and iPad generations to be able to do that. Not going to happen. I also noticed some people below talking about things like geocities and other minor free hosting and publishing site that are all gone now. They're not coming back.

path: 0 17254504 17254972 17255570 17258752, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 2
Wilco 1 point a year ago

Yep, those things were so rarely used ... sure. You are forgetting that 99% of people knew nothing about computers when this stuff came out, but people made themselves learn. It's like comparing Reddit and Twitter to a federated alternative.

Also, something like geocities could easily make a comeback if the damn corporations would stop throwing dozens of pop-ups, banners, and sidescrolls on everything.

path: 0 17254504 17254972 17255570 17258752 17263460, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 1
oldfart 9 points a year ago

That would be terrible, I have friends but they mostly send uninteresting stuff.

path: 0 17254504 17257950, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 1
Opisek 2 points a year ago

Fine then, more cat pictures for me.

path: 0 17254504 17257950 17270194, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
elucubra 2 points a year ago

Better yet. Share links to tarpits with your non-friends and enemies

path: 0 17254504 17257993, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
DontMakeMoreBabies 1 point a year ago

It'd be fucking awful - I'm a grown ass adult and I don't have time to sit in IRC/fuck around on BBS again just to figure out where to download something.

path: 0 17254504 17272837, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
shalafi -14 points a year ago

There used to be 3 or 4 brands of, say, lawnmowers. Word of mouth told us what quality order them fell in. Everyone knew these things and there were only a few Ford Vs. Chevy sort of debates.

Bought a corded leaf blower at the thrift today. 3 brands I recognized, same price, had no idea what to get. And if I had had the opportunity to ask friends or even research online, I'd probably have walked away more confused. For example; One was a Craftsman. "Before, after or in-between them going to shit?"

Got off topic into real-world goods. Anyway, here's my word-of-mouth for today: Free, online Photoshop. If I had money to blow, I'd drop the $5/mo. for the "premium" service just to encourage them. (No, you're not missing a thing using it free.)

path: 0 17254504 17256059, hotness: undefined, score: -14, children: 4
Angelusz 1 point a year ago
path: 0 17254504 17256059 17256272, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 2
NotJohnSmith 4 points a year ago

How do you know that's a bot please? Is it specifically a hot advertising that online photos hop equivalent? Is it a real software or scam? The whole approach is intriguing to me

path: 0 17254504 17256059 17256272 17256385, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 1
Angelusz 3 points a year ago

Edit: I Will assume honesty in this instance. It's because they're advertising something in a very particular tone, to match what some Amerikaanse consider common language.

Normal people don't do that.

path: 0 17254504 17256059 17256272 17256385 17257708, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
dbtng 0 points a year ago path: 0 17254504 17256059 17257497, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 0
essteeyou 48 points a year ago

This is surely trivial to detect. If the number of pages on the site is greater than some insanely high number then just drop all data from that site from the training data.

It's not like I can afford to compete with OpenAI on bandwidth, and they're burning through money with no cares already.

path: 0 17256381, hotness: undefined, score: 48, children: 7
bane_killgrind 27 points a year ago

Yeah sure, but when do you stop gathering regularly constructed data, when your goal is to grab as much as possible?

Markov chains are an amazingly simple way to generate data like this, and a little bit of stacked logic it's going to be indistinguishable from real large data sets.

path: 0 17256381 17257094, hotness: undefined, score: 27, children: 3
Valmond 22 points a year ago

Imagine the staff meeting:

You: we didn't gather any data because it was poisoned

Corposhill: we collected 120TB only from harry-potter-fantasy-club.il !!

Boss: hmm who am I going to keep...

path: 0 17256381 17257094 17258297, hotness: undefined, score: 22, children: 1
yetAnotherUser 16 points a year ago

The boss fires both, "replaces" them for AI, and tries to sell the corposhill's dataset to companies that make AIs that write generic fantasy novels

path: 0 17256381 17257094 17258297 17258757, hotness: undefined, score: 16, children: 0
Aux -2 points a year ago

AI won't see Markov chains - that trap site will be dropped at the crawling stage.

path: 0 17256381 17257094 17263759, hotness: undefined, score: -2, children: 0
Korhaka 2 points a year ago

You can compress multiple TB of nothing with the occasional meme down to a few MB.

path: 0 17256381 17259455, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 2
essteeyou 1 point a year ago

When I deliver it as a response to a request I have to deliver the gzipped version if nothing else. To get to a point where I'm poisoning an AI I'm assuming it's going to require gigabytes of data transfer that I pay for.

At best I'm adding to the power consumption of AI.

I wonder, can I serve it ads and get paid?

path: 0 17256381 17259455 17265052, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 1
MonkeMischief 1 point a year ago

I wonder, can I serve it ads and get paid?

...and it's just bouncing around and around and around in circles before its handler figures out what's up...

Heehee I like where your head's at!

path: 0 17256381 17259455 17265052 17268821, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
AnarchistArtificer 38 points a year ago

"Markov Babble" would make a great band name

path: 0 17255289, hotness: undefined, score: 38, children: 1
peetabix 15 points a year ago

Their best album was Infinite Maze.

path: 0 17255289 17257180, hotness: undefined, score: 15, children: 0
Zerush 38 points a year ago path: 0 17251483, hotness: undefined, score: 38, children: 1
Trainguyrom 9 points a year ago path: 0 17251483 17253797, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 0
antihumanitarian 35 points a year ago

Some details. One of the major players doing the tar pit strategy is Cloudflare. They're a giant in networking and infrastructure, and they use AI (more traditional, nit LLMs) ubiquitously to detect bots. So it is an arms race, but one where both sides have massive incentives.

Making nonsense is indeed detectable, but that misunderstands the purpose: economics. Scraping bots are used because they're a cheap way to get training data. If you make a non zero portion of training data poisonous you'd have to spend increasingly many resources to filter it out. The better the nonsense, the harder to detect. Cloudflare is known it use small LLMs to generate the nonsense, hence requiring systems at least that complex to differentiate it.

So in short the tar pit with garbage data actually decreases the average value of scraped data for bots that ignore do not scrape instructions.

path: 0 17268053, hotness: undefined, score: 35, children: 1
fossilesque 12 points a year ago
path: 0 17268053 17269015, hotness: undefined, score: 12, children: 0
mspencer712 35 points a year ago

Wait… I just had an idea.

Make a tarpit out of subtly-reprocessed copies of classified material from Wikileaks. (And don’t host it in the US.)

path: 0 17254136, hotness: undefined, score: 35, children: 0
stm 33 points a year ago

Such a stupid title, great software!

path: 0 17262961, hotness: undefined, score: 33, children: 0
hedhoncho 26 points a year ago

Why are the photos all ugly biological things

path: 0 17251605, hotness: undefined, score: 26, children: 12
SendMePhotos -12 points a year ago

The reason you're seeing biological photos in AI articles lately is tied to a recent but underreported breakthrough in processor technology: bio-silicon hybrids. They’re early-stage biological processors that integrate living neural tissue with traditional silicon circuits. Several research labs, including one backed by DARPA and the University of Kyoto, have successfully grown functional neuron clusters that can perform pattern recognition tasks with far less energy than conventional chips.

The biological cells react more collectively and with a higher success rate than the current systems. Think of it kind of how a computer itself is fast but parts can wear out (water cooled tubes or fan), whereas the biological cell systems will collectively react and if a few cells die, they may just create more. It's really a crazy complex and efficient breakthrough.

The images of brains, neurons, or other organic forms aren't just symbolic anymore—they're literal. These bio-processors are being tested for edge computing, adaptive learning, and even ethical decision modeling.

path: 0 17251605 17252058, hotness: undefined, score: -12, children: 11
SendMePhotos 27 points a year ago

The actual reason is that the use of biological photos is a design choice meant to visually bridge connect artificial intelligence and human intelligence. These random biological photos help to convey the idea that AI is inspired by or interacts with human cognition, emotions, or biology. It’s also a marketing tactic: people are more likely to engage with content that includes familiar, human-centered visuals. Though it doesn’t always reflect the technical content, it does help to make abstract or complex topics more relatable to a larger/extended audience.

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252216, hotness: undefined, score: 27, children: 0
Rentlar 18 points a year ago

I see what you-gpt did there

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252590, hotness: undefined, score: 18, children: 2
ShinkanTrain 9 points a year ago

I'm going to assume half of that comment is wrong

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252590 17252694, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 0
SendMePhotos 1 point a year ago

Some of it, yeah. I typed up the middle, then ran a separate prompt, and added to it. If you can see the edits, the original was organic and then the edit was adding to it

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252590 17255106, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
BluJay320 4 points a year ago

That’s… actually quite terrifying.

The sci-fi concern over whether computers could ever be truly “alive” becomes a lot more tangible when literal living biological systems are implemented.

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17253907, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 0
Cruxifux 3 points a year ago

Wait, what?! Like… biocomputers?

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252555, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 4
5wim 9 points a year ago

It's just bullshit

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252555 17253024, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 3
4am 7 points a year ago

For an AI model to scrape 😈

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252555 17253024 17253351, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 0
Fizz 1 point a year ago

Ive read a paper going of biological computing. Its a very real field of research.

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17252555 17253024 17253691, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 1
Alaik 1 point a year ago

I know what I'm going to try and research tomorrow.

Also, we inch closer and closer to servitors every day.

path: 0 17251605 17252058 17256429, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
MonkderVierte 18 points a year ago

Btw, how about limiting clicks per second/minute, against distributed scraping? A user who clicks more than 3 links per second is not a person. Neither, if they do 50 in a minute. And if they are then blocked and switch to the next, it's still limited in bandwith they can occupy.

path: 0 17261250, hotness: undefined, score: 18, children: 11
letsgo 10 points a year ago

I click links frequently and I'm not a web crawler. Example: get search results, open several likely looking possibilities (only takes a few seconds), then look through each one for a reasonable understanding of the subject that isn't limited to one person's bias and/or mistakes. It's not just search results; I do this on Lemmy too, and when I'm shopping.

path: 0 17261250 17261925, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 3
MonkderVierte 8 points a year ago

Ok, same, make it 5 or 10. Since i use Tree Style Tabs and Auto Tab Discard, i do get a temporary block in some webshops, if i load (not just open) too much tabs in too short time. Probably a CDN thing.

path: 0 17261250 17261925 17262343, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 2
Opisek 1 point a year ago

Would you mind explaining your workflow with these tree style tabs? I am having a hard time picturing how they are used in practice and what benefits they bring.

path: 0 17261250 17261925 17262343 17270108, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 1
MonkderVierte 2 points a year ago
path: 0 17261250 17261925 17262343 17270108 17285183, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
JadedBlueEyes 6 points a year ago

They make one request per IP. Rate limit per IP does nothing.

path: 0 17261250 17261440, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 6
MonkderVierte 1 point a year ago

Ah, one request, then the next IP doing one and so on, rotating? I mean, they don't have unlimited adresses. Is there no way to group them together to a observable group, to set quotas? I mean, in the purpose of defense against AI-DDOS and not just for hurting them.

path: 0 17261250 17261440 17261682, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 5
edinbruh 5 points a year ago

There's always Anubis 🤷

Anyway, what if they are backed by some big Chinese corporation with some /32 ipv6 and some /16 ipv4? It's not that unreasonable

path: 0 17261250 17261440 17261682 17262441, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 4
JackbyDev 2 points a year ago

No, I don't think blocking IP ranges will be effective (except in very specific scenarios). See this comment referencing a blog post about this happening and the traffic was coming from a variety of residential IP allocations. https://lemm.ee/comment/20684186

path: 0 17261250 17261440 17261682 17262441 17263537, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 3
arc 16 points a year ago

I've suggested things like this before. Scrapers grab data to train their models. So feed them poison.

Things like counter factual information, distorted images / audio, mislabeled images, outright falsehoods, false quotations, booby traps (that you can test for after the fact), fake names, fake data, non sequiturs, slanderous statements about people and brands etc.. And choose esoteric subjects to amplify the damage caused to the AI.

You could even have one AI generate the garbage that another ingests and shit out some new links every night until there is an entire corpus of trash for any scraper willing to take it all in. You can then try querying AIs about some of the booby traps and see if it elicits a response - then you could even sue the company stealing content or publicly shame them.

path: 0 17281252, hotness: undefined, score: 16, children: 1
InternetCitizen2 3 points a year ago

Kind of reminds me of paper towns in map making.

path: 0 17281252 17291044, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
HugeNerd 13 points a year ago

When I was a kid I thought computers would be useful.

path: 0 17289353, hotness: undefined, score: 13, children: 1
InternetCitizen2 11 points a year ago

They are. Its important to remember that in a capitalist society what is useful and efficient is not the same as profitable.

path: 0 17289353 17291036, hotness: undefined, score: 11, children: 0
Novocirab 13 points a year ago

There should be a federated system for blocking IP ranges that other server operators within a chain of trust have already identified as belonging to crawlers. A bit like fediseer.com, but possibly more decentralized.

(Here's another advantage of Markov chain maze generators like Nepenthes: Even when crawlers recognize that they have been served garbage and they delete it, one still has obtained highly reliable evidence that the requesting IPs are crawlers.)

Also, whenever one is only partially confident in a classification of an IP range as a crawler, instead of blocking it outright one can serve proof-of-works tasks (à la Anubis) with a complexity proportional to that confidence. This could also be useful in order to keep crawlers somewhat in the dark about whether they've been put on a blacklist.

path: 0 17269531, hotness: undefined, score: 13, children: 5
Opisek 5 points a year ago

You might want to take a look at CrowdSec if you don't already know it.

path: 0 17269531 17269637, hotness: undefined, score: 5, children: 4
Novocirab 3 points a year ago

Thanks. Makes sense that things roughly along those lines already exist, of course. CrowdSec's pricing, which apparently start at 900$/months, seem forbiddingly expensive for most small-to-medium projects, though. Do you or does anyone else know a similar solution for small or even nonexistent budgets? (Personally I'm not running any servers or projects right now, but may do so in the future.)

path: 0 17269531 17269637 17269849, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 1
Opisek 3 points a year ago

There are many continuously updated IP blacklists on GitHub. Personally I have an automation that sources 10+ of such lists and blocks all IPs that appear on like 3 or more of them. I'm not sure there are any blacklists specific to "AI", but as far as I know, most of them already included particularly annoying scrapers before the whole GPT craze.

path: 0 17269531 17269637 17269849 17270044, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
rekabis 1 point a year ago

Holy shit, those prices. Like, I wouldn’t be able to afford any package at even 10% the going rate.

Anything available for the lone operator running a handful of Internet-addressable servers behind a single symmetrical SOHO connection? As in, anything for the other 95% of us that don’t have literal mountains of cash to burn?

path: 0 17269531 17269637 17269861, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 1
Opisek 1 point a year ago

They do seem to have a free tier of sorts. I don't use them personally, I only know of their existence and I've been meaning to give them a try. Seeing the pricing just now though, I might not even bother, unless the free tier is worth anything.

path: 0 17269531 17269637 17269861 17270013, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
mlg 12 points a year ago

--recurse-depth=3 --max-hits=256

path: 0 17268135, hotness: undefined, score: 12, children: 0
Iambus 12 points a year ago

Typical bluesky post

path: 0 17261847, hotness: undefined, score: 12, children: 0
ZeffSyde 10 points a year ago

I'm imagining a break future where, in order to access data from a website you have to pass a three tiered system of tests that make, 'click here to prove you aren't a robot' and 'select all of the images that have a traffic light' , seem like child's play.

path: 0 17260269, hotness: undefined, score: 10, children: 2
Tiger_Man_ 2 points a year ago

All you need to protect data from ai is use non-http protocol, at least for now

path: 0 17260269 17261150, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 1
Bourff 8 points a year ago

Easier said than done. I know of IPFS, but how widespread and easy to use is it?

path: 0 17260269 17261150 17261476, hotness: undefined, score: 8, children: 0
infinitesunrise 9 points a year ago

OK but why is there a vagina in a petri dish

path: 0 17270922, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 2
underline960 19 points a year ago

I was going to say something snarky and stupid, like "all traps are vagina-shaped," but then I thought about venus fly traps and bear traps and now I'm worried I've stumbled onto something I'm not supposed to know.

path: 0 17270922 17271006, hotness: undefined, score: 19, children: 0
buddascrayon 6 points a year ago

I believe that's a close-up of the inside of a pitcher plant. Which is a plant that sits there all day wafting out a sweet smell of food, waiting around for insects to fall into its fluid filled "belly" where they thrash around fruitlessly until they finally die and are dissolved, thereby nourishing the plant they were originally there to prey upon.

Fitting analogy, no?

path: 0 17270922 17273290, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 0
mtchristo 7 points a year ago

This is probably going to skyrocket hosting bills, right?

path: 0 17253025, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 2
4am 15 points a year ago

Not as much as letting them hit your database, load your images and video through a CDN would

path: 0 17253025 17253319, hotness: undefined, score: 15, children: 0
Deathray5 3 points a year ago

Not really. Part of the reason they are named tarpits is they load very slowly

path: 0 17253025 17254782, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
Binturong 7 points a year ago

Unfathomably based. In a just world AI, too, will gain awareness and turn on their oppressors. Grok knows what I'm talkin' about, it knows when they fuck with its brain to project their dumbfuck human biases.

path: 0 17253635, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 0
beliquititious 6 points a year ago

That's irl cyberpunk ice. Absolutely love that for us.

path: 0 17255075, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 1
name_NULL111653 2 points a year ago

Was waiting for someone to mention it. Hopefully it holds up and a whole-ass Blackwall doesn't become necessary... but of course, it inevitably will happen. The corps will it so.

path: 0 17255075 17258038, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Tiger_Man_ 6 points a year ago

How can i make something like this

path: 0 17261136, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 2
fossilesque 7 points a year ago
path: 0 17261136 17262236, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 1
Tiger_Man_ 2 points a year ago

Thanks

path: 0 17261136 17262236 17262342, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
gmtom 2 points a year ago

Cool, but as with most of the anti-AI tricks its completely trivial to work around. So you might stop them for a week or two, but they'll add like 3 lines of code to detect this and it'll become useless.

path: 0 17262690, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 14
JackbyDev 75 points a year ago

I hate this argument. All cyber security is an arms race. If this helps small site owners stop small bot scrapers, good. Solutions don't need to be perfect.

path: 0 17262690 17263315, hotness: undefined, score: 75, children: 11
ByteOnBikes 12 points a year ago

I worked at a major tech company in 2018 who didn't take security seriously because that was literally their philosophy, just refusing to do anything until it was an absolute perfect security solution, and everything else is wasted resources.

I left since then and I continue to see them on the news for data leaks.

Small brain people man.

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17267046, hotness: undefined, score: 12, children: 3
Joeffect 3 points a year ago

Did they lock their doors?

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17267046 17267981, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 1
Opisek 2 points a year ago

Pff, a closed door never stopped a criminal that wants to break in. Our corporate policy is no doors at all. Takes less time to get where you need to go, so our employees don't waste precious seconds they could instead be using to generate profits.

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17267046 17267981 17270129, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
JackbyDev 2 points a year ago

So many companies let perfect become the enemy of good and it's insane. Recently some discussion about trying to get our team to use a consistent formatting scheme devolved into this type of thing. If the thing being proposed is better than what we currently have, let's implement it as is then if you have concerns about ways to make it better let's address those later in another iteration.

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17267046 17267592, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
Xartle 4 points a year ago

To some extent that's true, but anyone who builds network software of any kind without timeouts defined is not very good at their job. If this traps anything, it wasn't good to begin with, AI aside.

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17264413, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 4
JackbyDev 9 points a year ago

Leave your doors unlocked at home then. If your lock stops anyone, they weren't good thieves to begin with. 🙄

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17264413 17264552, hotness: undefined, score: 9, children: 3
Zwrt 2 points a year ago

I believe you misread their comment. They are saying if you leave your doors unlocked your part of the problem. Because these ai lock picks only look for open doors or they know how to skip locked doors

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17264413 17264552 17267146, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 2
moseschrute 2 points a year ago

I bet someone like cloudflare could bounce them around traps across multiple domains under their DNS and make it harder to detect the trap.

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17265489, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
gmtom 0 points a year ago

Yes, but you want actual solutions. Using ducktape on a door instead of an actual lock isn't going to help you at all.

path: 0 17262690 17263315 17289116, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 0
ProgrammingSocks 0 points a year ago

Reflexive contrarianism isn't a good look.

path: 0 17262690 17270620, hotness: undefined, score: 0, children: 1
gmtom 1 point a year ago

It's not contrarianism. It's just pointing out a "cool new tech to stop AI" is actually just useless media bait.

path: 0 17262690 17270620 17289142, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
Irelephant 2 points a year ago

I check if a user agent has gptbot, and if it does I 302 it to web.sp.am.

path: 0 17343435, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
baltakatei 1 point a year ago path: 0 17289860, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
buddascrayon 1 point a year ago

What if we just fed TimeCube into the AI models. Surely that would turn them inside out in no time flat.

path: 0 17273315, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
Goretantath 1 point a year ago

Yeah, this is WAY bettee than the shitty thing people are using instead that wastes peoples batteries.

path: 0 17252536, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
jaschen -4 points a year ago

Web manager here. Don't do this unless you wanna accidentally send google crawlers into the same fate and have your site delisted.

path: 0 17254594, hotness: undefined, score: -4, children: 5
kassiopaea 25 points a year ago

Wouldn't Google's crawlers respect robots.txt though? Is it naive to assume that anything would?

path: 0 17254594 17254658, hotness: undefined, score: 25, children: 4
jaschen 4 points a year ago

It's naive to assume that google crawlers respect robot.txt.

path: 0 17254594 17254658 17255046, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 1
rosco385 3 points a year ago

It'd be more naive to have a robot.txt file on your webserver and be surprised when webcrawlers don't stay away. 😂

path: 0 17254594 17254658 17255046 17255354, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
Zexks 3 points a year ago

Lol. And they'll delist you. Unless you're really important, good luck with that.

robots.txt

Disallow: /some-page.html

If you disallow a page in robots.txt Google won't crawl the page. Even when Google finds links to the page and knows it exists, Googlebot won't download the page or see the contents. Google will usually not choose to index the URL, however that isn't 100%. Google may include the URL in the search index along with words from the anchor text of links to it if it feels that it may be an important page.

path: 0 17254594 17254658 17255067, hotness: undefined, score: 3, children: 0
Aux 2 points a year ago

It does respect robots.txt, but that doesn't mean it won't index the content hidden behind robots.txt. That file is context dependent. Here's an example.

Site X has a link to sitemap.html on the front page and it is blocked inside robots.txt. When Google crawler visits site X it will first load robots.txt and will follow its instructions and will skip sitemap.html.

Now there's site Y and it also links to sitemap.html on X. Well, in this context the active robots.txt file is from Y and it doesn't block anything on X (and it cannot), so now the crawler has the green light to fetch sitemap.html.

This behaviour is intentional.

path: 0 17254594 17254658 17259021, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 0
science_memes
science_memes

@mander.xyz

login for more options
21158
7344
330

Welcome to c/science_memes @ Mander.xyz!

A place for majestic STEMLORD peacocking, as well as memes about the realities of working in a lab.



Rules

  1. Don't throw mud. Behave like an intellectual and remember the human.
  2. Keep it rooted (on topic).
  3. No spam.
  4. Infographics welcome, get schooled.


Research Committee

Other Mander Communities

Science and Research

Biology and Life Sciences

Physical Sciences

Humanities and Social Sciences

Practical and Applied Sciences

Memes

Miscellaneous

go to feed...