The blind hope that somewhere in this world there is a functioning public transit system is all that keep me going some days. Let me have this
ahornsirup 22 points 2 years ago
It's a problem of reliability. If you need to be at work at 08:00 and your train is regularly late or getting cancelled, you can't take the train to work.
PlzGivHugs 2 points 2 years ago
Halve of the scheduled trains didn't run today in Belgium.
Only half were cancelled? Man, that sounds nice.
rockerface 10 points 2 years ago
Ukraine wasn't completely horrible... before 2022 :(
NoneOfUrBusiness 9 points 2 years ago
Japan is the MVP here. I live there and I literally have never seen a train not arrive exactly at the scheduled time. However "public" transport is privately owned so... Uh... Yeah, tradeoffs.
ivanafterall 4 points 2 years ago
Given that it works so well, what are the negatives due to being private? Is it expensive to ride?
NoneOfUrBusiness 9 points 2 years ago
Is it expensive to ride?
Yeah. It also stops running at around 11 or 12 so if you stay out late you just might find you can't get back home.
isolatedscotch 6 points 2 years ago
I've been in Vienna from time to time, and it's pretty good, 365€/year for the pass that gets you buses, trams and subways with unlimited access and no turnstiles anywhere, you just go and enter
Schedules follow work hours and go from a subway every 2 minutes during peak hours to one every 15mins late at night
You have night line buses for weekdays and on Saturday night public transport doesn't shut down
Coverage is good, you almost always have a bus or tram line less then 5 minutes of walking
There are bike sharing places with 20 bikes each ~1km apart and they cost 60 cents for half an hour, or e-scooters in the designed locations which are basically everywhere (but being owned by companies they cost so much more then everything else)
rafagnious 3 points 2 years ago
Honestly, the perspective of what constitutes a functioning public transit system depends a lot on what you have as a point of reference.
I'm portuguese but I lived in Germany for 5 months during which I used exclusively public transports and bikes. Central Europeans complain a lot about Deutsche Bahn and indeed during this time I saw a few strikes, delays and suppressions. However, transports were still much more reliable and much more frequent than I'm used too so I could never really consider it problematic, although my Central European friends complained a lot.
fishy 2 points 2 years ago
I take the light rail into work from the suburbs of Seattle into downtown. Trains run every 7-8 minutes. They're expanding it in all directions now. Only downside is that a lot of homeless ride the train because it's cold as heck on the streets. That's a societal problem though, not an issue with the train.
HobbitFoot 23 points 2 years ago
If you're German, RIP in peace.
criss_cross 12 points 2 years ago
A German intern came to our american city and was flabbergasted that the trains here ran consistently.
I had a laugh since I always assumed it'd be the opposite.
ultranaut 14 points 2 years ago
As an American, this is exactly correct. The last time I tried to take Amtrak the train literally did not show up and they told us they had no way to contact it and didn't know where it was. After waiting many hours with no change in status I finally gave up. The last time I actually rode Amtrak it was multiple hours late and cost about the same as a plane ticket.
peoplebeproblems 8 points 2 years ago
But, I bet the train didn't fall apart in air, and didn't crash because of overwhelmed ATC
conditional_soup 3 points 2 years ago
Like, you lost the train? Did you look under the couch?
idegenszavak 10 points 2 years ago
Peak moments of MÁV (Hungarian State Railways)
- Soviet tractor overtakes train (2024): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5wkW1nKfJY
- Man in snail costume outruns train (2018): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1WAY1sFM6yQ
- Passengers pushing the train to the station (2021): https://www.youtube.com/shorts/bNUWNxt-lyg
Cethin 7 points 2 years ago
I think watching Jet Lag let's you see the full breadth of transit systems pretty well, because the whole game relies on it. Japan is amazing. A lot of Europe is good enough that you can get around, some great and some not so great. The US is so bad I don't think either team bothered taking a train when they did the show there.
ivanafterall 3 points 2 years ago
I hear Italian trains are very timely?
bilb 2 points 2 years ago
Not to downplay any of the myriad problems here in the USA, but I think many of us are trying to believe that a better world is possible and this sometimes leads to unrealistic views of how much better things are abroad. Sometimes.
But I am hopeful that this country is increasingly humiliated for at least a couple of decades.
circuitfarmer 90 points 2 years ago
Japanese transit users: "Don't worry, we can grab the next one. It will be here in 48 seconds."
Cort 46 points 2 years ago
We deeply apologize that it took the train 49 seconds to arrive. We have prepared notes for your boss in case you're late, and there will be a half page ad in tomorrow's paper confirming our CEO has committed seppuku to atone.
LovableSidekick 5 points 2 years ago
Spock: Forty eight point three seven seconds, Captain.
circuitfarmer 2 points 2 years ago
*except on one of the all-female trains
kersploosh 66 points 2 years ago
Wait, you guys have trains?
MrVilliam 22 points 2 years ago
there's always one when you need to cross the tracks.
This, but you ever notice that it's pretty much never passenger trains? This efficient mode of transportation is largely designed for and used by industry rather than for travel or commute. The exception is within big enough cities like DC and NYC to get from one side of the city to the other or anywhere between. Sure there are some trains that go between cities, but they're largely unreliable because passenger cars yield to industrial freight, and so people are less inclined to opt for them over planes or cars, and so there are fewer trains available to go wherever you're going in the window you're trying to go. So you book a flight instead.
I'd take a long train ride over a road trip any fucking day. I don't understand anybody who would rather drive than chill and read a book or play games or watch movies or nap.
PugJesus 24 points 2 years ago
This, but you ever notice that it’s pretty much never passenger trains? This efficient mode of transportation is largely designed for and used by industry rather than for travel or commute.
Yet massive amounts of goods are shipped long-distance via truck anyway, clogging up highways and polluting far more per-ton and per-mile moved.
Truly the worst of both worlds! USA! USA! USA!
0ops 2 points 2 years ago
Exactly, it's not that the US doesn't have trains, there are plenty. Lots of relatively small towns have rails going to or through them. The problem is that only a tiny fraction of them are passenger rail.
drew_belloc 7 points 2 years ago
Got it, always cross the tracks
kersploosh 6 points 2 years ago
Stand on the tracks to summon the train.
drew_belloc 7 points 2 years ago
The train needs a human sacrifice
theneverfox 16 points 2 years ago
Oh yeah, we have so many trains. They go everywhere, we have a very comprehensive network of them
Oh wait... Did you mean passenger trains?
doingthestuff 57 points 2 years ago
As an American, I don't have access to trains, buses, bike lanes, sidewalks or even a shoulder on the road. The last time I tried to walk home from the tire shop two miles away, three people stopped to offer me a ride because it is that dangerous. I live inside the 275 loop that runs around Cincinnati.
Mic_Check_One_Two 45 points 2 years ago
Yeah, my “Public Transit” option on google maps is entirely greyed out. This is my daily commute to work:
It’s always entertaining to see the Europeans go “lol just ditch your car, it has to start somewhere” like it wouldn’t require me to move my entire family across town, (and pay 3x as much rent to live in the city…) Like I don’t even have the option of taking public transit, because there are no connecting lines between my home and my job. Literally none. The nearest bus stop is almost as far away as my job, and it’s in the opposite direction.
And to be clear, that 2+ hour walk would be on a highway with no sidewalk. I’d be dead on day 1. If I wanted to avoid the highway, the walk would be closer to 4.5 hours; The highway is the only direct path.
Retrograde 20 points 2 years ago
That's so sad that it's just greyed out lol. Even google maps is like, nah you're fucked dude
Natanox 6 points 2 years ago
To be fair, Google Maps sucks ass in this regard. If you ever visit Europe, never EVER trust it for public transit information. Always look on the native apps and websites. Google Maps regularly offers me routes that either don't exist anymore, not at that time or day of the week, unnecessarily require a group taxi somewhere or are simply extremely inefficient. Instead of a 95min travel it wanted me to go for a route that took 145 minutes the last time (luckily I knew it was bullshit).
Even FOSS apps that may acquire travel data through rather novel means will provide more accurate information than the billions of dollars available to Googles car heads.
perviouslyiner 1 point 2 years ago
It actually found some useful routes in Scotland that the bus website couldn't tell you about - e.g. where there's no direct route somewhere, but you can go to a place near the junction of some routes and wait for a bus in the other direction.
LordWiggle 7 points 2 years ago
I live in Utrecht, one of The Netherlands' larger cities. I don't even have a car anymore. I can reach any place in the city by cycling in 15min max. Planning a trip with Google maps often shows cycling to be as fast or even faster than by car. Amsterdam by train is 30min, train leaves every 10min. I can take my bike in the train or take a public transportation bike from any train station. Cars are stupid.
doingthestuff 2 points 2 years ago
I lived a year in Nijmegen when I was younger, and later another year in Duesseldorf, so what you're describing isn't foreign to me. But where I live now there are no options other than car. If you don't own one you need a friend with one or an Uber.
LordWiggle 1 point 2 years ago
Damn, that sucks. I never have to worry about traffic, I have no time delay when traveling during rush hour by bike. More people on bikes means less cars, less traffic jams. I don't understand why other countries move away from cars, there are only benifits and no downsides switching to a stronger public transit and cycling infrastructure. It unclugs traffic so businesses have faster travel times, there are less accidents, the city is cleaner, there is more room to build as there is less need for parking space, road maintenance is cheaper, the cities get a better feeling for being in as people are invited to be in the streets instead of their cars. There's more room for greenery, which has a mental benifit as well as rainwater management. Kids can play on the streets safely again instead. It's not hard to do. Rotterdam was rebuilt after the second world war when it was wiped from the map by German bombing. They built it up like American cities, completely car focused. They completely changed it to bike friendly because of accidents and clogging, making a very shitty city a very nice one.
sucoiri 1 point 2 years ago
How easy is it for you to take your bike on the train in that area? I was visiting Utrecht recently and was really surprised they only allowed 2-3 bikes on the entire train (off peak hours too).
LordWiggle 2 points 2 years ago
I avoid rush hour because people are annoying. I usually have no issue with bringing my bike, most of the times there are a few bike areas on each train and when it's 5 instead of 3 while people can still pass the hallway no one would care about it. But it's just as easy to use a bike from NS (national railway), they are at every station and it's cheap. A folding bike is free to take by train, I might buy an electric one in the future.
VitoRobles 3 points 2 years ago
I did this math recently. To walk to work would take me either a 2 hour walk, a 17 minute drive, or a 45 minute bus ride.
timbuck2themoon 1 point 2 years ago
Transit outside the actual city, of any kind, is pretty abysmal.
LordWiggle 46 points 2 years ago
Although there are many improvements to be made, like international euro rail connecting the capitals, better prices, a reliable DB and most importantly EU standard track system, I love our euro rails.
But I've gotta confess, the fact the US train is called Marc is kinda cool.
"Hey, I wonder where Marc is. Is he coming?"
"Nah men, Marc is completely derailed again. He burned down an entire town and he's toxic AF."
genuineparts 6 points 2 years ago
Well at least Marc never comes prematurely.
melpomenesclevage 6 points 2 years ago path: 0 15760775 15763632, hotness: undefined, score: 6, children: 1
callouscomic 6 points 2 years ago
Don't forget BART and DART as well.
a_wild_mimic_appears 1 point 2 years ago
should have named them BORT and BURT
jellyfishhunter 26 points 2 years ago
Too early
theyllneverfindmehere 11 points 2 years ago
As a DB user: "ha!"
pedz 4 points 2 years ago
DB doesn't hold a candle to VIA Rail. Germans and Europeans in general like to mock DB, and with reason, but as a Canadian, I'm still so very jealous of DB.
Due to [these] restrictions, 80 per cent of trips suffered delays of more than 10 to 15 minutes in February between Quebec City and Windsor, where the majority of Via trains operate. In January, 67 per cent of trains were late on the same corridor. Delays have been even greater between Quebec City and Ottawa this year, affecting 94 per cent of trains last month and 86 per cent in January.
horse 4 points 2 years ago
DB uses this novel trick to avoid delays: they simply don't count trains that don't run at all as delayed. And then they also sometimes cancel trains for being delayed. They simply turn the train around before reaching it's final stop so at least it's somewhat on time running the other way.
ivanafterall 11 points 2 years ago
It's a nice train, that must be like the capital of Europe?
LordWiggle 8 points 2 years ago
Don't give Xi any ideas
privsecfoss 32 points 2 years ago
The problem with trains is they are public (under)founded. The rich and powerfull with political influence don't want working public transportation because less carsales, oil, gasoline etc.
Which explains why Musk prevented a high speed train in the US with his hyperloop. We all need to buy EV"s which have most of the downsides of traditional cars.
When we could have clean, fast and comfortable public transportation.
EDIT: Spelling.
privsecfoss 1 point 2 years ago
Agreed. Politicians should prioritize trains and public transport more. And bicycles while we're at it.
JayDee 13 points 2 years ago
Which is why he prevented delayed a high speed train in the US. To my knowledge, they are still constructing it.
Just checked: it's still underway. 119 miles currently under construction. From Bakersfield to Madera, with most of the rail near Madera completed.
hausthatforrem 3 points 2 years ago
Because everyone dreams of ending up in Bakersfield...
privsecfoss 1 point 2 years ago
Good to hear! Didn't know that. Good news.
Little8Lost 6 points 2 years ago
Trains need to be public or you are gonna get a second DB (it enshittifies for some time now ;.;)
barsoap 3 points 2 years ago
DB is still 100% owned by the federation, it's only organised privately. Trouble is they expected it to turn a profit, to do that DB had to run its infrastructure into the ground, invest abroad, get into fucking trucking, you name it. Don't get me wrong there's nothing wrong with operating rail/road interface warehouses, but when a rail company is building a logistics warehouse without rail connection you know something's deeply fishy. Meanwhile, the Autobahn network got plenty of tax money pumped into it. And those DB profits.
The failure is 110% political, decades of car-brained infrastructure ministers, "but won't someone think about the car producers and their workers". Bipartisan issue. In US terms: UAW and Blackrock vs. Amtrack. Guess who's winning the lobby battle, difference being in Germany people actually like trains.
privsecfoss 1 point 2 years ago
Agree 100%. But where I live politicians always seem to focus more on giving tax cuts than maintenance and improving trains. The people should not accept it, but.. Tax cuts!
gandalf_der_12te 1 point 2 years ago
I'm considering it should be a private company where the state/city is the majority owner.
Also i'm guessing that the public transport only makes sense in cities, and inter-city. Not so much on the countryside in small villages. There cars are more efficient.
gandalf_der_12te 30 points 2 years ago
funny but inaccurate
i live in vienna. the train comes so often, nobody bothers to check the schedule anymore. just wait 2 mins, enter, go.
JargonWagon 30 points 2 years ago
American here - I recently started taking the train to go to work! Previously I couldn't due to no trains scheduled for the return home trip after my shift was over, but after getting a new schedule, I got on board the train! So far in the past two months, I've already had a few instances of the train being delayed or missing it entirely. One day, the train was delayed by 30 minutes and stated they would be held for an unknown amount of time to put out a fire on the tracks at a station ahead - drove into work that day. Another day, the train was delayed by 5 minutes. Outside of that, I was late to the train by like 5 minutes and it left without me (still adjusting to early morning schedule).
So far, I like taking the train much more than driving the car.
lud 8 points 2 years ago
Of course the trains leave without you if you are 5 min late.
It will leave without you if you are 30 seconds late. Hell, it will even leave if you are 5 seconds late unless they see you running and are feeling extra nice.
JargonWagon 5 points 2 years ago
Never said it shouldn't! Just means it's running on time. Like I said, I'm still adjusting to the early schedule.
beejboytyson 4 points 2 years ago
I owned a car in Toronto. I still took the train DT. Driving DT literally was longer then the train.
przemek 2 points 2 years ago
I’m Polish but I also made the switch to use public transport instead of my car, even though it’s not the cheapest once you’re not a student anymore. I feel better though knowing how much fuel I save by not driving in traffic for 1.5h 4 days a week. The other thing is that the money goes to the city so I will likely benefit from it in some way
JargonWagon 1 point 2 years ago
And you also get a little bit of time to yourself! I use it to study for certs.
przemek 1 point 2 years ago
True, although this aspect is actually an area where I prefer driving. I find it relaxing to zone out my thoughts and just focus on what’s ahead of me with my favorite music. Depending on time of day, trains here are a bit tough to study in due to how many people there are
FossilVerbrechen 26 points 2 years ago
I am here to represent the germans. The country where the only thing we agree about is, how fucking shit our trains are
Two2Tango 4 points 2 years ago
I was late for a hair appointment because I missed the bus, and I swear they wrote it down in my file because every time I went back, for the next year they were like "So... Did you come by bus today?"
Also yeah no problem if your train doesn't come once - but if it happens more than once it's going to reflect badly even though it's out of your control. You'll start to get the comments "You should take the earlier one!" I travelled by bus with 2 transfers to college and it was ROUGH.
Tja 3 points 2 years ago
I used it every time it happened, very rarely when I just slept in. My boss also came by S-Bahn so he was late from time to time as well. Of course if we had an important meeting or a customer appointment we came in a whole hour early, to compensate for 3 train failures, which never happened. But if you came 20 minutes late on a regular Tuesday nobody cared that much (boring office IT job).
khannie 4 points 2 years ago
There's a classic that Irish rail used to pull out of their bag of shite excuses until they got slagged to death over it:
Leaves on the track.
No joke. C'mon now lads. In fairness though the train service in Dublin and inter-city is pretty reliable and reasonable.
kartoffelsaft 5 points 2 years ago
My understanding is that leaves contain some compound(s) that, when wet and under the extremely high pressures that train wheels provide, becomes one of the most effective lubricants we know about. In other words, the brakes literally won't do anything because you'll slip-n-slide your way at the same speed you were going before.
Natanox 5 points 2 years ago
Sounds like the Irish version of the german winter chaos. The very moment the first snowflake drops it's total chaos, trains being terminated left and right due to an old railway switch that still saw Adolf freezing shut again.
cows_are_underrated 24 points 2 years ago
Wait until you hear about German trains.
Don_alForno 21 points 2 years ago
Can't be late if it doesn't arrive at all.
Little8Lost 12 points 2 years ago
600 Minuten Später
cows_are_underrated 6 points 2 years ago
Also quasi pünktlich
missandry351 6 points 2 years ago
Portugals trains joined the chat
ExcessShiv 24 points 2 years ago
Where is this magical European place with trains that are only .5sec delayed? Our public transit authority considers train "on time" if they're no more than 20min late...and still, less than 80% of trains are "on time"...
TriflingToad 5 points 2 years ago
compared to my area where we don't even have busses, trains are a dream
geography082 23 points 2 years ago
Which eu countries? Most of eu countries are on second meme
LeninOnAPrayer 2 points 2 years ago
From my small experience as an a American. Netherlands had some really reliable transit. Never had a problem in France though definitely not as nice as Netherlands. Italy was definitely hit and miss depending on the city but loved the high speed rail from Naples to Rome. Germany was reliable during October Fest so I assume at least Munich is reliable if it was good at that time. Though I wouldn't say I used much in Germany.
Other countries I've been to but I'll just list cities for these because I didn't go much anyone else for them: Prague, Budapest, Vienna
I can't say there was a single country/city here that had transit that was worse than the best transit in the US. Was it all perfect? No. But compared to fucking Amtrak that literally has to stop for hours at a time while we wait for other freight trains to pass. Literally multiple times during a single train ride.
Some countries may not be the first meme. But what major city in Europe has worse local transit than say Chicago or New York? Or worse heavy rail than Amtrak? Just honestly asking.
I don't think anything could be worse than Amtrak.
geography082 1 point 2 years ago
You mentioned 4 - 5 EU countries, even major cities. You are missing other 22 countries. Not going too far like mentioning Romania, but have you ever tried Renfe en Madrid? Hehehe it fails many times
przemek 1 point 2 years ago
On the contrary, when I lived in the US on Long Island, a part of the country where people warn life without a car is impossible, I had a great transit experience. Buses were generally on time, modern and equipped with live tracking, and the trains were great too.
I know LI’s relative poor transit options are mostly in comparison to other areas in the Northeast, which is a densely populated region. I imagine my experience would be totally different in the Midwest or the Prairies. And that’s especially true for trains – LI is awesome in that regard
QualifiedKitten 22 points 2 years ago
As an American living in a region with halfway decent (by American standards) public transit, I feel like I hear more comments aligned with the European side than the American side. If public transit has literally any downsides, that's justification enough to drive for so many people.
melpomenesclevage 7 points 2 years ago path: 0 15760455 15763661, hotness: undefined, score: 7, children: 8
ShaggySnacks 3 points 2 years ago
Baby, people call me a 2-8-0 Locomotive. I can take you places that you never thought of.
melpomenesclevage 2 points 2 years ago path: 0 15760455 15763661 15764474 15771308, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 6
ShaggySnacks 2 points 2 years ago
I'm so hot, I'm constantly steaming. I'm generally a workhouse, carrying all that freight. Moving vast amount of passengers is no sweat for me.
LovableSidekick 7 points 2 years ago
Although the US and Europe are nearly identical in area, Europe's population centers are far more uniformly distributed. Big cities in America are mostly around the edges, with a vast, sparsely populated area in the middle. Most intercity train service in America is in that fringe, where the spacing between cities is more like in Europe.
AdrianTheFrog 8 points 2 years ago
And yet we don't have true hsr in the northeast, where the big cities are...
LovableSidekick 5 points 2 years ago
True, but the post is about trains being on schedule (or showing up at all), not about speed. I wasn't saying US trains service is as good as European.
AdrianTheFrog 6 points 2 years ago
Yeah, I just see that said a lot and think its a bad excuse for having bad service.
Especially when we had much better service 100 years ago, with a fraction of the modern day population.
melpomenesclevage 4 points 2 years ago path: 0 15760455 15761052 15761212 15763668, hotness: undefined, score: 4, children: 0
VonReposti 21 points 2 years ago
It's not like a BMW is more reliable.
peoplebeproblems 3 points 2 years ago
Does the blue electric smoke at least stay inside the jar while I'm leasing it?
spankmonkey 8 points 2 years ago
Yeah, but you can be stuck in traffic in your BMW without needing to interact with the poors!
theUwUhugger -3 points 2 years ago
What the actual fuck are you talking about?
VonReposti 13 points 2 years ago
BMW's are famously known to be in the workshop more often than on the road. My friend's BMW had a type of self-cleaning oil. All he has to do is top off the oil once a month. Just ignore the stain on the parking lot, it's not oil.
theUwUhugger 1 point 2 years ago path: 0 15752205 15752393 15752734 15765919, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
theUwUhugger 0 points 2 years ago
They are very sensitive and do require to regular cleanings and oil changes
But saying that they are less reliable since our regulations are so much stricter, no less to say that they less lasting is not only the silliest fucking thing I have heard all tuesday but objectively false
European cars generally last much longer than American vehicles
VonReposti 1 point 2 years ago
I'm European. I'm not talking about American cars.
And it's also a joke with a bit of truth to it. They do require much more care so they're more often in the workshop than, say a Toyota.
theUwUhugger 2 points 2 years ago
They are very sensitive and do need periodic cleanings and oil changes, but its really nothing you can’t do on your own?
But saying that they are less reliable since oir regulations are so much stricter, and to say less lasting is not only the silliest fucking thing I have heard all tuesday but objectively false
European cars generally last much longer than American vehicles
Vahenir 20 points 2 years ago
You clearly havent heard of swedish trains.
The railroad here is a bad joke at this point, mainly due to shutting down the organization that was responsible for maintainence and shoving it into another agency that has no clue. As a bonus the new agency doesn't even do the repair work themselves but hires contractors at the lowest bidder. So stuff breaks constantly, which causes delays.
At this point just getting the rail network to "normal" standards would cost billions. Let alone expanding it to cope with current traffic levels.
enumerator4829 3 points 2 years ago
To be fair, most higher density areas in Sweden have fairly good infrastructure for public transit. The national railways are a disgrace, but that mostly affects long distance travel. Mostly. Short to medium distance commute works fairly well everywhere I’ve tried it.
PalmTreeIsBestTree 1 point 2 years ago
Scandinavia has more in common with Canada when it comes to public transportation
PalmTreeIsBestTree 1 point 2 years ago
Their trains break down a lot and it’s a bigger joke
CrazyLikeGollum 19 points 2 years ago
Meanwhile in Japan: Train is 30 seconds late "here's a letter for your employer explaining why you were only 29 minutes and 30 seconds early for your 8 hour shift that will inevitably have an additional 8 hours of unpaid overtime tacked on to it."
randombullet 14 points 2 years ago
Deutsch Bahn would like a word.
I often take my car because it's so damn unreliable.
Not once, not twice, but three times I've sat on a train for 2+ hours without moving within the past 2 years.
starchylemming 11 points 2 years ago
working as intended. for several generations, the car lobby fills the management of deutsche bahn.
ThePyroPython 5 points 2 years ago
UK National Rail and the Franchise system: those are rookie numbers!
PugJesus 21 points 2 years ago
The origin of that saying, the trains in Fascist Italy, were basically never on time. But the fascist government put great effort into telling people that, at long last, they were running on time, so it stuck.
Narratives dig deeper into cultural consciousness than reality itself.
Ledericas 12 points 2 years ago
no fast railways in the US at all, hyperloop delayed cali long enough til trump was able to stop it in his first term. it would solve alot of employment locaitons issues like biotech, and tech hubs. which are situated outside of major freeways and highways and major metro areas, even cars have a trouble navigating to.
CalipherJones 12 points 2 years ago
Germany's known for having terrible rail. Probably on account of BMW lobbying.
NewDay 3 points 2 years ago
BMW, VW and Mercedes. The German Bundesbahn was perfect then the CDU, CSU and FDP killed it due to lobbyism. Now, the politicians suck the cocks of the CEOs of the mentioned companies. SPD and Grüne always say that the Deutsche Bahn needs more money, but they had the chance between 98 and 05. Did they change something? No there was not enough money according to them.
HK65 3 points 2 years ago
Not even the biggest thing that beautiful trio ruined. Their lobbying and Mutti Merkel's politics were the main contributors to the Hungary problem. So if you want to know why common defense policies get vetoed or why is the Ukraine response is a shitshow, the root cause is that VW needed cheap exploitable workers.
Olhonestjim 1 point 2 years ago
Really? As an American who had never ridden a train before, I was impressed by Germany's public transit. I remember wishing we had such systems everywhere over here.
Honestly though, I'd prefer high speed mag-lev systems that run like clockwork.
CalipherJones 2 points 2 years ago
Germany's known for poor rail, America's known for no rail.
A_Chilean_Cyborg 10 points 2 years ago
Me When My metro train (Santiago) doesn't immediately arrive as soon as i touch the platform.
rational_lib 10 points 2 years ago
American public transit varies widely, ranging from better than driving to comically horrible.
a_wild_mimic_appears 1 point 2 years ago
path: 0 15760088 15763377 15767416, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
chiliedogg 4 points 2 years ago
Trains specifically are bad on shared lielnes because passenger trains are lowest-priority rail traffic, so you can get delayed for days at a time.
bitMasque 1 point 2 years ago
Same here; I live across the world. Usually, I mean. As a visitor in Japan however, I can confirm that their public transit system is every bit as convenient and efficient as we've been lead to believe internationally. Believe the hype.
Tezzerets_Tea_Time 8 points 2 years ago
American here: yeah, not far off.
ZkhqrD5o 2 points 2 years ago
The reason I said it is because there are alternatives which are significantly cheaper and more effective. Maglev is expensive, shit ROI and massive downsides over conventional high-speed rail, namely system complexity and maintenance. Short version: expensive AF.
Edit: I've made another comment below. Also the French TGV has proven it can go 575 kilometers per hour, why not make regular trains even faster? It would be cheaper, would achieve the same thing and keeps the benefits of regular trains. There are always multiple approaches to the same problem, and the flashiest solution is seldom the best.
Asetru 2 points 2 years ago
I'm well aware that rail/wheel tech works well. However
It would be cheaper
is not true. High speed rail is precision engineering and what you gain from the reduced complexity of not having magnets on the rails is lost by the required precision to make trains as fast as you claim them to be. The cost for a Transrapid line was claimed to be pretty much on par with an ICE line, with trains carrying fewer people but on a higher frequency, so even that would have evened out. The advantage you claim, which is compatibility to existing rail networks, can be regarded as a disadvantage, too, as high speed trains suddenly compete for the same limited resource as all other trains in the network and are sometimes travelling quite slowly as they utilise the same, old rails because the pain of using the old network isn't big enough to make people build new high speed infrastructure. Add to that the issue of too many stops that are added for political reasons and high speed trains suddenly become less and less of a competitive player when it comes to international traffic. If there was another network that would simply be incompatible to existing ones, a lot of these issues wouldn't even arise. A Transrapid just wouldn't stop in Erkelenz, Züssow or Altenbeken and no overly confident mayor could even suggest it, simply because there wouldn't be the infrastructure. And that would be a good thing.
Also, the speed comparison is not that simple. You're comparing wheeled trains that took decades to evolve with the first generation of maglev trains and as far as I see, that's also the highest speed recorded, which isn't what they're allowed to do during regular operations. I highly doubt that there's no room for improvement to get faster for maglevs.
All that said, I'm well aware that "the train has passed". Europe uses wheels and I'm fine with that. I don't want to sound overly negative and I'm happy for every cm of rail that's built. It's just that high speed rail needs to up its game a bit if they want to compete with planes. Right now, they're still too slow. Next week I'll be in Italy for a conference... High speed trains would have taken 4 to 5 times as much time, so I ended up getting a plane ticket booked. That's a pity and had we built a maglev infrastructure 20 years ago, maybe it would have been better by now.
AdrianTheFrog 1 point 2 years ago
The estimated cost of construction of the maglev line in Japan is a bit less than 10% of the yearly U.S. military budget. The Northeast Corridor is about 10% longer, so let's round that to 11%. And I would be surprised if that infrastructure would not be used at least partially 100 years after construction.
Keep in mind that the proposal is to buy the technology from the SCMaglev people, which is something IIRC they indicated they were supportive of doing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_Maglev
It's currently stuck in an indefinitely paused environmental review as far as I can tell, due to no one caring about it I guess
ZkhqrD5o 1 point 2 years ago
I am staunchly anti-maglev for different reasons. Firstly, it's incompatible with other systems. Building it is expensive as hell because of the awkward way you have to build the rails of magnets which the train will then glide upon. Since every centimetre of the train needs magnets to be floating above the rails, the trains themselves are incredibly short and expensive for their capacity. Short version, you need a lot more trains, which are significantly more expensive for the same capacity of a normal train. A hundred years sounds impressive, but for example, a railway tunnel with conventional rails has only the drive wire and the rails, which will need to be exchanged in the future. The tunnel itself can be easily used for hundreds of years most states calculate with 200 though. Speed isn't everything, capacity is. The Austrian railjet only drives 230 km/h because you don't need to make the train airtight, meaning for 2 million (2008 money) plus two eurosprinters (5 mil a pop, todays money) you get 500 meters of railjet, which can transport approximately 1,400 people. Also, the railjet can just be separated into two 250m trainsets and the go into two completely different directions. All of these are benefits that Maglev hasn't got. It's more expensive and can do less. But it does go fast, admittedly. But at what cost is this speed gained? And is it really the most important thing if 250 people can reach something twice as fast as a contemporary high-speed train? Also, the French TGV has proven it can go 575 km/h, So even in that regard, if you were to reduce it to the engines in the front and the back in a single passenger car, you basically have Maglev, but for a fraction of the price.
AdrianTheFrog 1 point 2 years ago
I would be surprised if the French TGV can go into tunnels at those speeds, or maintain them safely 24-7. Also, the 100 years figure is one I completely made up based on what I've seen from conventional trains, I have no idea how long maglev track actually lasts.
Also, the scmaglev is advertised to be able to hold up to 728 people in the 12 car configuration, and can probably reach high frequencies similar to the rest of the shincansen system.
Speed matters for people to actually want to use trains, and maglevs are supposed to be both much faster and even more comfortable than conventional rail. They are a proven technology by this point.
Yes, it's not cheap, but it has the ability to significantly improve rail service in the northeast, and as the richest country in the world surely we should be able to afford that.
The other argument I've seen is that we have to go through all of the trouble and lawsuits around obtaining a new right of way anyways, even for normal high speed rail, so we may as well put the best technology available there.
conditional_soup 6 points 2 years ago
This shit keeps me up at night while I play STALKER. America feels like the Zone sometimes; nobody's in control, there's a tendency to romanticize our shitty trashcore setting, everyone's just living get-rich-quick scheme to get-rich-quick scheme, and there's bloodsuckers and pigs everywhere. At least the zone is pedestrian-pilled.
JackRider 7 points 2 years ago
It's funny, but after traveling around Europe, I've learned one important lesson: avoid booking flights with short layovers! If the transfer time is less than 3-4 hours, you’re playing a risky game. Delays happen more often than you'd think, and in some cases, flights get pushed to the next day due to 'bad weather' (or other mysterious reasons). Better to have a buffer than to get stuck at the airport overnight!
ramenshaman 7 points 2 years ago
San Francisco Bay Area resident checking in. I think we have some of the best public transit in the US, which is pretty shit compared to most urban areas in Europe and Asia. Our trains come frequently enough and are generally on-time but the coverage is pretty bad. Public transit in SF can be pretty unpleasant though.
projektilski 6 points 2 years ago
You haven't seen Croatian rail then ;)
VitabytesDev 6 points 2 years ago
Meanwhile in Greece:
Grizzlyboy 6 points 2 years ago
Most of my country doesn't have trains. The only train on time goes to the airport, yes THE airport. Everything else is buss for train. And I purposely didn't mention the country but everyone from here knows it when they read buss for train.
missandry351 5 points 2 years ago
Portugal is in America 😂😂😂😂😂 and it’s gotten way worse since the pandemic
RymrgandsDaughter 4 points 2 years ago
Nice the train is only 15 minutes late? That's awesome - me riding any train in the US
thelemonalex 3 points 2 years ago
Wait until you hear about Spanish trains.
Deconceptualist 2 points 2 years ago
Big Money Wasted
imouto 2 points 2 years ago
The one on the left seems to be a Chinese train tho https://en.m.wikipedia.org/...
KillingTimeItself 2 points 2 years ago
american trains look better and nobody will ever pry that fact from my cold dead hands.
Little8Lost 2 points 2 years ago
You clearly need to look at more train pictures
I am sure there are magnificent american trains but some american trains are probably ugly too
My point is: beauty is not bound by borders and there is so much out there
KillingTimeItself 2 points 2 years ago
all the euro trains look like futuristic renders of trains, american trains make me feel happy.
euro trains will simply never compare, also the E bell goes hard, and you will never take that away from me.
AnonomousWolf 1 point 2 years ago path: 0 15760169 15766053, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 5
KillingTimeItself -1 points 2 years ago
can't say i have, but im assuming it's safe to say they look pretty boring.
AnonomousWolf 2 points 2 years ago path: 0 15760169 15766053 15778197 15783521, hotness: undefined, score: 2, children: 3
KillingTimeItself 0 points 2 years ago
based on the american trains that i live around.
IDK, they're just more visually pleasing to me. European trains just look like the proof of concept render of what a train will look like.
doingthestuff 3 points 2 years ago
Probably because of the reputation of BMW drivers in the US. And the reputation for cost and frequency of maintenance and repairs in the US. A lot of people have a thing against beamers.
fishy 3 points 2 years ago
Most people don't hate BMW's or their drivers, it's a joke that they're all stuck up a-holes. There's similar jokes for people driving Tesla's being oblivious (fascists too now lol), Nissan Altima drivers being incredibly reckless, Prius' for always going 15 under the limit in the passing lane, etc.
I saw an e46 323 for $2000 yesterday, it's also a cheap option here.
Shou 1 point 2 years ago
I get it though. I love driving cars, busses and trucks. It's a lot of fun. But the fun isn't worth the resources it takes to make, maintain and pollute.
Honestly. I wish my country wasn't sacked by the rich who "wanted to lower taxes" but only ended up decreasing the funding for essential services. Services the poor rely on more than the rich. Healthcare and public education mainly. If we didn't have vampires at the helm, we'd probably have more taxes going to public services. And heck, I would have loved our country to pay tax for "free" public transport. That would be so much more efficient, safe and affordable for everyone.
Because rn, my LPG chevrolet spark is more affordable than a train subscription. Gonna give my ol car to a family member though. She needs it more. Living in a rural area and needing to travel pretty far for her work. Public transport would be 1.5-2hrs travel while driving is about 45min.
Realitaetsverlust -7 points 2 years ago
Unless you're living in austria or switzerland (which technically isn't europe but lets roll with it), you will never have trains on time.
CaptainBlagbird 3 points 2 years ago
Well, we're in the mountains above Europe, I guess.
Realitaetsverlust 1 point 2 years ago
I quite obviously wasn't talking about the country.
Realitaetsverlust 1 point 2 years ago
I am well aware. The part in brackets only referred to switzerland.
RandomVideos 1 point 2 years ago path: 0 15757497 15765665, hotness: undefined, score: 1, children: 0
memes
@lemmy.world
23024
10606
10542
Community rules
1. Be civil
No trolling, bigotry or other insulting / annoying behaviour
2. No politics
This is non-politics community. For political memes please go to !politicalmemes@lemmy.world
3. No recent reposts
Check for reposts when posting a meme, you can only repost after 1 month
4. No bots
No bots without the express approval of the mods or the admins
5. No Spam/Ads/AI Slop
No advertisements or spam. This is an instance rule and the only way to live. We also consider AI slop to be spam in this community and is subject to removal.
A collection of some classic Lemmy memes for your enjoyment
Sister communities
- !tenforward@lemmy.world : Star Trek memes, chat and shitposts
- !lemmyshitpost@lemmy.world : Lemmy Shitposts, anything and everything goes.
- !linuxmemes@lemmy.world : Linux themed memes
- !comicstrips@lemmy.world : for those who love comic stories.
go to feed...
memes
@lemmy.world
23024
10606
10542
Community rules
1. Be civil
No trolling, bigotry or other insulting / annoying behaviour
2. No politics
This is non-politics community. For political memes please go to !politicalmemes@lemmy.world
3. No recent reposts
Check for reposts when posting a meme, you can only repost after 1 month
4. No bots
No bots without the express approval of the mods or the admins
5. No Spam/Ads/AI Slop
No advertisements or spam. This is an instance rule and the only way to live. We also consider AI slop to be spam in this community and is subject to removal.
A collection of some classic Lemmy memes for your enjoyment
Sister communities
- !tenforward@lemmy.world : Star Trek memes, chat and shitposts
- !lemmyshitpost@lemmy.world : Lemmy Shitposts, anything and everything goes.
- !linuxmemes@lemmy.world : Linux themed memes
- !comicstrips@lemmy.world : for those who love comic stories.
go to feed...
As a European I have to say, you are very optimistic about our train schedules.
save